# Evaluation Report: x-ipe-task-based-application-knowledge-extractor
# Round 4: Evaluate Results
# Date: 2025-07-14

evaluation_report:
  skill_name: x-ipe-task-based-application-knowledge-extractor
  date: "2025-07-14"

  summary:
    total_tests: 58
    must_pass_total: 44
    must_pass_passed: 43
    must_pass_rate: "97.7%"
    should_pass_total: 11
    should_pass_passed: 11
    should_pass_rate: "100%"
    could_have_total: 3
    could_have_passed: 3

  verdict: FAIL
  # FAIL because must_pass_rate != 100% (43/44)
  # Only 1 must_pass test failed: TC-041

  failures:
    - id: TC-041
      type: must_pass
      category: edge_case
      name: "Empty directory halts with error"
      reason: >
        SKILL.md Step 1.1 (Analyze Input) does not explicitly handle empty
        directories as a separate DECISION branch. The procedure has a generic
        catch-all ("Cannot classify input type") but lacks the specific error
        message "Input directory is empty" that the test case expects. The
        examples.md file (Example 4) shows this error, but the procedure
        itself does not include an explicit check for empty directories before
        attempting input type classification. Fix: Add a DECISION branch in
        Step 1.1 that checks if the target directory is empty and returns a
        specific error message.

  quality_observations:
    - id: OBS-001
      severity: minor
      description: >
        SKILL.md uses escaped backticks (\`\`\`yaml) in 6 out of 8 code blocks
        instead of regular backticks (```yaml). This is a formatting defect that
        would cause markdown renderers to display raw backtick characters instead
        of syntax-highlighted code blocks. The XML code block (```xml) uses
        regular backticks correctly. Fix: Replace all escaped backtick sequences
        with regular triple backticks.

    - id: OBS-002
      severity: info
      description: >
        Line count is 494/500 — very close to the limit. Future additions
        should consider extracting content to reference files.

    - id: OBS-003
      severity: info
      description: >
        DoD has exactly 10 checkpoints (the maximum). Any additions would
        require consolidation.

  quality_scores:
    structure: 5/5
    # All 12 sections present in correct order, frontmatter valid,
    # <input_init> XML block present, DoR/DoD within limits,
    # Execution Flow table complete, Phase Definitions complete,
    # reference and template files all present
    content: 4/5
    # All behavioral tests pass — input detection, tool skill loading,
    # checkpoint protocol, category selection, error handling all described.
    # -1 for missing explicit empty directory handling (TC-041) and
    # escaped backtick formatting defect (OBS-001)
    behavior: 5/5
    # All behavioral/procedural tests pass: input type detection for all 5
    # types, app type detection (web/cli/mobile/unknown), tool skill glob
    # discovery, category validation, checkpoint creation, mode-aware review
    # gate, DAO routing, happy path scenarios, edge cases (except TC-041),
    # blocking scenarios, design alignment with technical design
    overall: 4/5
    # Excellent skill quality overall. One must_pass failure (TC-041) and
    # one formatting defect (escaped backticks) prevent a 5/5 rating.
    # Both are straightforward fixes.

  notes: >
    The skill is very close to passing. Only 1 must_pass test failed (TC-041:
    empty directory handling). The fix is surgical — add a DECISION branch in
    Step 1.1 to check for empty directories before input type classification.
    Additionally, the escaped backtick formatting in code blocks (OBS-001)
    should be fixed to ensure proper markdown rendering. Both fixes are
    low-risk and localized. After these fixes, the skill should achieve
    100% must_pass rate and full PASS verdict.

  recommended_fixes:
    - priority: P0
      test_id: TC-041
      fix: >
        In SKILL.md Step 1.1 DECISION section, add before the input type
        classification: "IF target is directory AND directory is empty (0 files)
        → halt with error: 'Input directory is empty'"

    - priority: P1
      observation_id: OBS-001
      fix: >
        Replace all escaped backtick sequences (\`\`\`) with regular triple
        backticks (```) in SKILL.md code blocks. Affects Input Parameters,
        Input Initialization validation, Output Result, and inline code
        references.
