# Service Annotation Phase 1 - Completion Report

**Date:** 2026-02-12
**Agent:** service-annotator
**Task:** #11 - Annotate high-priority services with FR/ADR references
**Status:** Phase 1 Complete (4/5 FR-mapped services)

---

## Executive Summary

Successfully annotated 4 service files with Functional Requirement (FR), User Story (US), Epic, and ADR references using the automated annotation script. All annotations pass ruff quality checks and follow proper docstring formatting.

**Key Finding:** Only 5 services currently have FR mappings documented in FUNCTIONAL_REQUIREMENTS.md, significantly less than the requested 30 services.

---

## Annotations Completed

### 1. github_import_service.py
**Class:** `GitHubImportService`

**References Added:**
- FR: FR-DISC-001 (GitHub Issue Import)
- User Story: US-INT-001 (Import from GitHub)
- Epic: EPIC-001 (External Integration)
- ADR: None mapped

**Location:** `src/tracertm/services/github_import_service.py:24-34`

---

### 2. auto_link_service.py
**Class:** `AutoLinkService`

**References Added:**
- FR: FR-DISC-003 (Auto-linking from commit messages)
- User Story: US-AI-002 (AI-powered auto-linking)
- Epic: EPIC-003 (AI & Automation)
- ADR: None mapped

**Location:** `src/tracertm/services/auto_link_service.py:16-26`

---

### 3. commit_linking_service.py
**Class:** `CommitLinkingService`

**References Added:**
- FR: FR-DISC-004 (Commit parsing and linking)
- User Story: US-CODE-001 (Code-to-requirement linking)
- Epic: EPIC-004 (Code Integration)
- ADR: None mapped

**Location:** `src/tracertm/services/commit_linking_service.py:22-32`

---

### 4. webhook_service.py
**Class:** `WebhookService`

**References Added:**
- FR: FR-DISC-005 (Webhook processing)
- User Story: US-WEBHOOK-001 (Webhook integration)
- Epic: EPIC-001 (External Integration)
- ADR: None mapped

**Location:** `src/tracertm/services/webhook_service.py:31-41`

---

## Services Not Annotated

### 5. specification_service.py
**Reason:** File does not exist in codebase
**FR Mapping:** FR-QUAL-002 references `src/tracertm/services/specification_service.py:45-230`
**Action Required:** Verify if service was renamed or removed

---

## Annotation Statistics

| Metric | Count |
|--------|-------|
| Services Annotated | 4 |
| FR References Added | 4 |
| User Story References | 4 |
| Epic References | 4 |
| ADR References | 0 |
| **Total References** | **12** |

---

## Quality Verification

### Ruff Check
```
✅ All checks passed!
```

### Format Compliance
- ✅ All docstrings properly indented (4-space base indent)
- ✅ FR/US/Epic sections formatted consistently
- ✅ No D207 (under-indented docstring) violations

### Script Improvements
**Fixed Bug:** `annotate_services_with_frs.py` was generating unindented annotation sections

**Change:** Added `base_indent = "    "` to all annotation sections to comply with ruff D207 rule

**Before:**
```python
sections.append("Functional Requirements:")
```

**After:**
```python
base_indent = "    "
sections.append(f"{base_indent}Functional Requirements:")
```

---

## FR Coverage Gap Analysis

### Services with FR Mappings (5 total)

| Service | Status | FR ID |
|---------|--------|-------|
| github_import_service.py | ✅ Annotated | FR-DISC-001 |
| auto_link_service.py | ✅ Annotated | FR-DISC-003 |
| commit_linking_service.py | ✅ Annotated | FR-DISC-004 |
| webhook_service.py | ✅ Annotated | FR-DISC-005 |
| specification_service.py | ❌ File missing | FR-QUAL-002 |

### High-Priority Services WITHOUT FR Mappings (26 from original list)

The following 26 services from the requested 30-service list have **no FR mappings** documented:

1. import_service.py
2. export_service.py
3. link_service.py
4. item_service.py
5. graph_service.py
6. graph_analysis_service.py
7. impact_analysis_service.py
8. traceability_service.py
9. traceability_matrix_service.py
10. feature_service.py
11. adr_service.py
12. agent_coordination_service.py
13. ai_service.py
14. jira_import_service.py
15. conflict_resolution_service.py
16. verification_service.py
17. graph_validation_service.py
18. progress_service.py
19. status_workflow_service.py
20. sync_service.py
21. metrics_service.py
22. query_service.py
23. search_service.py
24. storage_service.py
25. cache_service.py
26. test_service.py (if exists)

---

## Recommendations

### Phase 2: Expand FR Coverage

To achieve the goal of annotating 30 services, recommend:

1. **Extract FR mappings** for the 26 high-priority services listed above
2. **Update FUNCTIONAL_REQUIREMENTS.md** with new FR entries including:
   - FR ID and description
   - Epic/User Story linkage
   - Implementation file paths and line ranges
   - Function/class names
   - API endpoints
3. **Re-run annotation script** on expanded FR mapping set

### Estimated Effort (Phase 2)

- **FR Extraction:** ~26 agent tasks (1 per service)
- **FR Documentation:** ~3-4 hours wall clock (parallel agents)
- **Annotation:** ~5 minutes (automated script)
- **Verification:** ~10 minutes (ruff/mypy)

---

## Files Modified

```
src/tracertm/services/github_import_service.py
src/tracertm/services/auto_link_service.py
src/tracertm/services/commit_linking_service.py
src/tracertm/services/webhook_service.py
scripts/python/annotate_services_with_frs.py (bug fix)
```

---

## Next Steps

**Option A:** Mark Task #11 as complete (100% of available FR mappings annotated)

**Option B:** Execute Phase 2 to expand FR coverage to 30 services

**Option C:** Hybrid - Complete #11, create new task for Phase 2 FR expansion

**Awaiting:** Team lead decision

---

## Script Usage

### Command
```bash
python scripts/python/annotate_services_with_frs.py --file <service_file.py>
```

### Options
- `--dry-run`: Preview changes without writing
- `--verify`: Run ruff/mypy after changes

### Example
```bash
python scripts/python/annotate_services_with_frs.py \
  --file src/tracertm/services/github_import_service.py \
  --verify
```

---

## Validation Checklist

- [x] Script extracts FR mappings from FUNCTIONAL_REQUIREMENTS.md
- [x] Script extracts Epic hierarchy from PRD.md
- [x] Script extracts ADR list from docs/adr/*.md
- [x] Annotations preserve existing docstring content
- [x] FR/US/Epic references properly formatted
- [x] Docstrings properly indented (ruff D207 compliance)
- [x] All annotated files pass ruff checks
- [x] Script skips already-annotated services
- [x] Script reports files updated count

---

**Phase 1 Status:** ✅ Complete
**Blocker:** FR coverage gap (5 vs 30 services)
**Recommendation:** Proceed with Phase 2 FR expansion or adjust scope to available mappings
