---
docType: review
layer: project
reviewType: tasks
slice: structured-review-findings
project: squadron
verdict: PASS
sourceDocument: project-documents/user/tasks/143-tasks.structured-review-findings.md
aiModel: minimax/minimax-m2.7
status: complete
dateCreated: 20260330
dateUpdated: 20260330
---

# Review: tasks — slice 143

**Verdict:** PASS
**Model:** minimax/minimax-m2.7

## Findings

### [PASS] All success criteria mapped to tasks

Each of the 9 success criteria from the slice design has corresponding task coverage:
- SC1 (review file with findings): T5 (formatter) + T10 (verification)
- SC2 (finding fields): T1 (model) + T5 (formatter)
- SC3 (importable): T1
- SC4 (property): T1
- SC5 (JSON output): T7
- SC6 (NOTE severity): T1 + T3
- SC7 (category extraction): T3 + T9
- SC8 (backward compatibility): T10
- SC9 (type checks): T10

### [PASS] Test files correctly identified for each implementation task

- T2: `tests/review/test_models.py` (extend)
- T4: `tests/review/test_parsers.py` (extend)
- T6: `tests/cli/test_review_format.py` (create if needed)
- T8: `tests/review/test_models.py` (extend)

### [PASS] Proper test-with pattern maintained

Implementation tasks (T1, T3, T5, T7) are immediately followed by their corresponding test tasks (T2, T4, T6, T8), maintaining the test-after pattern throughout.

### [PASS] Commit checkpoints distributed appropriately

- T1: `feat: add StructuredFinding model and NOTE severity`
- T2: `test: add structured finding model tests`
- T3: `feat: extend parser for NOTE severity, category, and location extraction`
- T4: `test: add parser tests for NOTE, category, and location extraction`
- T5: `feat: emit structured findings in review frontmatter`
- T6: `test: add frontmatter structured findings formatter tests`
- T7+T8: `feat: add structured findings to JSON serialization` (combined, acceptable)
- T9: `feat: add structured output instructions to review prompts`
- T10: `docs: mark slice 143 structured review findings complete`

### [PASS] Task dependencies respected

- Models (T1) before model tests (T2)
- Parser (T3) before parser tests (T4)
- Formatter (T5) before formatter tests (T6)
- JSON (T7) before JSON tests (T8)
- T9 (prompt) positioned after core implementation, before final verification (T10)

### [PASS] No scope creep detected

All tasks trace to explicit slice design requirements. No tasks introduce functionality outside the stated scope of "StructuredFinding model, extend ReviewFinding, extend ReviewResult, extend parser, extend frontmatter formatter, extend to_dict(), prompt enhancement."

### [PASS] Tasks are independently completable

Each task has clear success criteria and can be verified independently by a junior AI. Sub-tasks within each task are well-bounded.

### [PASS] Task granularity is appropriate

- T1 (model changes) is the largest task but the sub-items are tightly coupled (all in `models.py`)
- T10 (verification) is appropriately larger as a final integration checkpoint
- No tasks are excessively granular
