---
docType: review
reviewType: slice
slice: scoped-code-review-prompt-logging
project: squadron
verdict: PASS
dateCreated: 20260325
dateUpdated: 20260325
---

# Review: slice — slice 127

**Verdict:** PASS
**Model:** minimax/minimax-m2.7

## Findings

### [PASS] Correct scope within Review System

The slice modifies only the `squadron/review/` subsystem and CLI commands, which are explicitly defined in the architecture's project structure. The new `git_utils.py` module follows the established pattern for utility modules within the codebase.

### [PASS] Appropriate dependency boundaries

Dependencies flow correctly from the Interface Layer (CLI commands) down to the Review System (review_client, models), without creating inappropriate coupling to the Core Engine or Agent Provider Layer. The slice correctly targets only the review workflow enhancement.

### [PASS] SDK path limitation appropriately documented

The slice explicitly notes that prompt logging applies only to the non-SDK path, since the SDK manages its own prompts internally. This is documented as a known limitation rather than a bug. The architecture's separation between SDK and API agent providers is respected.

### [PASS] Graceful degradation design

The design correctly implements fallback behavior: if branch detection or merge commit finding fails, the system falls back to `--diff main` with a warning rather than failing. This aligns with the architecture's principle of robust, recoverable operations.

### [PASS] New module organization follows conventions

The addition of `squadron/review/git_utils.py` follows the existing module organization pattern shown in the architecture. The component structure diagram in the slice correctly maps to the existing project layout.

### [PASS] Test coverage requirements aligned with architecture quality bar

The slice specifies unit tests for all three resolution paths (branch exists, merged, fallback), prompt log writer, and debug appendix formatting. This matches the architecture's implied emphasis on testable core components.
