# QUINE VALIDATION RESULTS

## Project Goal
Validate SpecSoloist specifications by regenerating all framework code from specs, ensuring specifications are complete and implementation-ready.

## Execution Summary

**Status: ✅ SUCCESS**

All 14 code-generating specs in `score/` compiled to working Python code with comprehensive test coverage. 4 documentation-only specs (`type: specification`) were correctly skipped.

## Compilation Results by Level

### Level 0: Foundation (No Dependencies) — 6 specs
✅ **schema** — Pydantic models for spec interfaces + Arrangement types
✅ **config** — Configuration management with PydanticAI provider support
✅ **ui** — Terminal UI utilities using Rich; configure/quiet/json-mode support
✅ **manifest** — Build manifest for incremental builds
✅ **resolver** — Dependency graph and topological sort
✅ **compiler** — LLM prompt construction; arrangement + reference spec injection

### Level 1: Parsing & Execution (Depends on Level 0) — 4 specs
✅ **parser** — Spec file discovery, parsing, reference type + verification snippet support
✅ **runner** — Test execution with sandboxing support
✅ **respec** — Reverse engineering source code to specs
✅ **build_diff** — Semantic comparison of build output directories

### Level 2: Orchestration (Depends on Level 0, 1) — 2 specs
✅ **core** — SpecSoloistCore orchestrator; arrangement + reference spec handling
✅ **composer** (spechestra) — SpecComposer: plain English → architecture → specs

### Level 3: CLI & Integration (Depends on Level 0–2) — 2 specs
✅ **cli** — Full CLI with sp init, vibe, diff, status, doctor, install-skills; --quiet/--json
✅ **conductor** (spechestra) — SpecConductor: parallel builds + environment provisioning

### Skipped (type: specification — documentation only)
⏭️ **spec_format** — Spec format documentation
⏭️ **arrangement** — Arrangement schema documentation
⏭️ **specsoloist** — Package overview documentation
⏭️ **spechestra** — Package overview documentation

## Overall Test Results

```
Total Tests Passing: 320/320 ✅
Success Rate: 100%
```

## Output Structure

All compiled code is located in: `/home/toby/_code/symbolfarm/specsoloist/build/quine/`

```
build/quine/
├── src/
│   ├── specsoloist/
│   │   ├── schema.py
│   │   ├── config.py
│   │   ├── ui.py
│   │   ├── manifest.py
│   │   ├── resolver.py
│   │   ├── compiler.py
│   │   ├── parser.py
│   │   ├── runner.py
│   │   ├── respec.py
│   │   ├── build_diff.py
│   │   ├── core.py
│   │   └── cli.py
│   └── spechestra/
│       ├── composer.py
│       └── conductor.py
└── tests/
    ├── test_schema.py
    ├── test_config.py
    ├── test_ui.py
    ├── test_manifest.py
    ├── test_resolver.py
    ├── test_compiler.py
    ├── test_parser.py
    ├── test_runner.py
    ├── test_respec.py
    ├── test_build_diff.py
    ├── test_core.py
    ├── test_composer.py
    ├── test_conductor.py
    └── test_cli.py
```

## What Changed Since Last Run (2026-02-09)

Score specs updated to reflect ~20 features shipped in Phase 8 and Phase 9:

| Change | Specs Updated |
|--------|--------------|
| `type: reference` spec type | `parser.spec.md`, `compiler.spec.md`, `core.spec.md`, `spec_format.spec.md` |
| Arrangement `dependencies` field | `schema.spec.md`, `arrangement.spec.md` |
| Arrangement `env_vars` field | `schema.spec.md`, `arrangement.spec.md`, `cli.spec.md` |
| Arrangement `model` field + `_resolve_model()` | `schema.spec.md`, `cli.spec.md` |
| `sp init --template` | `cli.spec.md` |
| `sp conduct --resume` / `--force` | `conductor.spec.md`, `cli.spec.md` |
| `sp diff` (spec-drift + build-diff) | `build_diff.spec.md` (new), `cli.spec.md` |
| `--quiet` / `--json` flags | `cli.spec.md`, `ui.spec.md` |
| `sp vibe`, `sp status`, `sp doctor`, `sp install-skills` | `cli.spec.md` |
| PydanticAI provider | `config.spec.md` |
| Renamed Conductor → SpecConductor (simplified) | `conductor.spec.md` (full rewrite) |
| Renamed Composer → SpecComposer | `composer.spec.md` |
| `build_diff.py` added to specsoloist | `build_diff.spec.md` (new code-gen spec) |
| `quine_diff.spec.md` removed (superseded) | deleted |
| Non-code specs marked `type: specification` | `specsoloist.spec.md`, `spechestra.spec.md`, `arrangement.spec.md` |

## Validation Criteria Met

✅ `sp conduct score/ --model claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 --auto-accept` completes without errors
✅ `PYTHONPATH=build/quine/src uv run python -m pytest build/quine/tests/ -q` passes with 0 failures
✅ All score specs accurately describe the current `src/`
✅ New features (reference spec type, arrangements, PydanticAI, sp vibe/diff/status) all covered

---

**Generated**: 2026-03-19
**Model**: claude-haiku-4-5-20251001
**Total Tests**: 320
**Pass Rate**: 100%
