# SEF-Agents Compliance & PR Review Metrics - Summary

> **Generated by:** Forensic Engineer
> **Date:** 2026-01-09

---

## Code Quality Metrics (pe_rules)

| Rule ID | Metric | Target |
|---------|--------|--------|
| **E001** | Bare `except:` clauses | **0** violations |
| **E002** | `except Exception` without re-raise | **0** violations |
| **T001** | Missing return type hints | **< 5%** of public functions |
| **D001** | Missing docstrings (public functions) | **< 10%** of public APIs |
| **D002** | Placeholder docstrings (`TODO`, `...`) | **0** violations |
| **D003** | Missing `Args:` section (functions with params) | **< 15%** |
| **D004** | Missing module docstring | **< 20%** of modules |
| **L001** | `print()` statements in production code | **0** violations |
| **L002** | `logging.*` instead of `structlog` | **0** violations |
| **L003** | f-strings in logger calls | **< 10%** |
| **I001** | Import order violations | **0** violations |

---

## TypeScript/JavaScript Quality Metrics

| Rule ID | Metric | Target |
|---------|--------|--------|
| **TS-ANY** | `: any` type usage | **0** violations |
| **TS-IGNORE** | `@ts-ignore` / `@ts-nocheck` | **0** violations |
| **TS-CONSOLE** | `console.log()` in production | **0** violations |
| **TS-EMPTY** | Empty catch blocks | **0** violations |
| **TS-RETURN** | Missing return type annotations | **< 10%** of functions |
| **TS-NULLABLE** | Non-null assertion (`!`) overuse | **< 5%** |
| **TS-PROMISE** | Promises not awaited (`.then()` chains) | **< 10%** |
| **JS-VAR** | `var` instead of `let`/`const` | **0** violations |
| **JS-EVAL** | `eval()` usage | **0** violations |
| **JS-INNERHTML** | `.innerHTML` assignment (XSS risk) | **0** violations |
| **JS-EQUALITY** | `==` instead of `===` | **0** violations |
| **JS-MUTATION** | Direct state mutation | **0** violations |

---

## React-Specific Metrics

| Rule ID | Metric | Target |
|---------|--------|--------|
| **REACT-KEY** | Missing `key` prop in lists | **0** violations |
| **REACT-STATE** | Direct state mutation | **0** violations |
| **REACT-DEPS** | useEffect missing dependencies | **0** violations |
| **REACT-DOM** | Direct DOM manipulation | **0** violations |
| **REACT-LIFECYCLE** | Deprecated lifecycle methods | **0** violations |
| **REACT-INLINE** | Inline styles | **< 10%** of components |
| **REACT-ANON** | Anonymous function props | **< 20%** |
| **REACT-PROPS** | Component props count | ≤ 5 props per component |
| **REACT-HOOKS** | Hooks per component | ≤ 4 hooks per component |
| **REACT-SIZE** | Component size | ≤ 100 lines |
| **REACT-DRILLING** | Prop drilling depth | ≤ 2 levels |

---

## Angular-Specific Metrics

| Rule ID | Metric | Target |
|---------|--------|--------|
| **NG-SUBSCRIBE** | Subscriptions without unsubscribe | **0** violations |
| **NG-ANY** | `$any()` in templates | **0** violations |
| **NG-DOM** | Direct DOM access | **0** violations |
| **NG-TRACKBY** | `*ngFor` without trackBy | **< 10%** |
| **NG-HTTP** | Deprecated Http module | **0** violations |
| **NG-COMPAT** | rxjs-compat usage | **0** violations |
| **NG-METHODS** | Component methods count | ≤ 7 methods per component |
| **NG-SERVICES** | Injected services count | ≤ 4 services per component |
| **NG-I18N** | Hardcoded strings | **< 20%** of templates |

---

## Compliance Validation

| Rule ID | Metric | Target |
|---------|--------|--------|
| **MCP001** | `@mcp.tool()` without docstring | **0** violations |
| **TS001** | `: any` type usage (TypeScript) | **0** violations |
| - | Code-echoing comments | **0** violations |
| - | Docstring fluff | **0** violations |

---

## Technical Debt Metrics

| Metric | Target |
|--------|--------|
| **TODO/FIXME** comments | **< 20** per 10k LOC |
| **Deprecated imports** | **0** violations |
| **High complexity** (cyclomatic > 12) | **< 5%** of functions |
| **Long functions** (> 50 LOC) | **< 10%** of functions |
| **Deep nesting** (> 3 levels) | **< 10%** of functions |

---

## Complexity Thresholds

| Metric | Target |
|--------|--------|
| **Cyclomatic Complexity** | ≤ 12 |
| **Function Length** | ≤ 50 lines |
| **Nesting Depth** | ≤ 3 levels |
| **File Length** | ≤ 300 lines |
| **Comment Ratio** | ≤ 0.4 |
| **Class-to-Function Ratio** | ≤ 0.5 |

---

## AI Anti-Patterns

| Pattern | Target |
|---------|--------|
| **Over-abstraction** | Class/Function ratio ≤ 0.5 |
| **Generic naming** | < 10% of identifiers |
| **Copy-paste blocks** | Similarity < 85% |
| **Verbose comments** | Comment ratio ≤ 0.4 |

---

## Security Metrics

| Scan Type | Target |
|-----------|--------|
| **Secret detection** | **0** exposed secrets |
| **Network imports** (unsafe) | **0** violations |
| **Outbound URLs** (unregistered) | **0** violations |
| **Dependency vulnerabilities** | **0** critical CVEs |
| **Unsafe file operations** | **0** violations |
| **License violations** | **0** GPL/AGPL in proprietary |

---

## Quality Gates

| Gate | Target |
|------|--------|
| **Code Coverage** | ≥ 80% |
| **Test Pass Rate** | 100% |
| **Linter** (Ruff/ESLint) | 0 errors |
| **Type Checker** (mypy/TypeScript) | 0 errors |
| **Security Scan** | PASS |

---

## Health Score Calculation

```
Health Score = 100 - (CRITICAL × 10 + HIGH × 3 + MEDIUM × 1 + LOW × 0.1)
```

**Thresholds:**
- **≥ 90:** ✅ Excellent
- **70-89:** ⚠️ Good
- **50-69:** 🟡 Needs Improvement
- **< 50:** 🔴 Critical

---

**Document Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2026-01-09
