# Validation Report: Story 3-2 Create Queue Operation Context

**Document:** docs-bmad/sprint-artifacts/stories/3-2-create-queue-operation.context.xml
**Checklist:** .bmad/bmm/workflows/4-implementation/story-context/checklist.md
**Date:** 2025-12-29_21-38-02

## Summary
- Overall: 10/10 passed (100%)
- Critical Issues: 0

## Section Results

### Story Context Completeness
Pass Rate: 10/10 (100%)

✓ **PASS** - Story fields (asA/iWant/soThat) captured
Evidence: Lines 13-15 contain all three user story fields properly extracted from story markdown:
- asA: "DevOps engineer"
- iWant: "to create queues with configurable properties (durability, TTL, DLX, etc.)"
- soThat: "I can provision messaging infrastructure matching my application requirements"

✓ **PASS** - Acceptance criteria list matches story draft exactly (no invention)
Evidence: Lines 96-103 contain all 8 acceptance criteria from the story draft verbatim. No additional criteria invented. Format matches original with numbered list structure.

✓ **PASS** - Tasks/subtasks captured as task list
Evidence: Lines 16-93 contain complete task list with all 8 tasks and their subtasks in markdown checkbox format, matching story draft exactly. Task descriptions preserved including AC references.

✓ **PASS** - Relevant docs (5-15) included with path and snippets
Evidence: Lines 107-188 contain 10 documentation artifacts:
1. tech-spec-epic-3.md (Data Models)
2. tech-spec-epic-3.md (APIs and Interfaces)
3. tech-spec-epic-3.md (Workflows and Sequencing)
4. 3-1-list-queues-operation.md (Key Patterns)
5. 3-1-list-queues-operation.md (Project Structure)
6. epic-3-topology-operations.md (Technical Notes)
7. test-design-system.md (Unit Testing)
8. test-design-system.md (Integration Testing)
9. ADR-008-Type-Safety-Pydantic
10. ADR-009-Structured-Logging
All include project-relative paths, titles, sections, and relevant snippets.

✓ **PASS** - Relevant code references included with reason and line hints
Evidence: Lines 189-236 contain 7 code artifacts:
- topology.py operations (ListQueuesOperation pattern reference)
- topology.py schemas (QueueDetails reuse, CreateQueueRequest location)
- http_client.py (HTTPClientManager for HTTP calls)
- executor.py (OperationExecutor base pattern)
- test_topology.py (schema test patterns)
- test_list_queues_operation.py (operation test patterns)
- test_list_queues_integration.py (integration test patterns)
All include project-relative paths, kind, symbol, line hints, and clear reasons for relevance.

✓ **PASS** - Interfaces/API contracts extracted if applicable
Evidence: Lines 253-277 contain 5 interface definitions:
- HTTP PUT /api/queues/{vhost}/{name} (create endpoint)
- HTTP GET /api/queues/{vhost}/{name} (idempotency check)
- CreateQueueRequest Pydantic schema signature
- CreateQueueOperation.execute() async method signature
- HTTPClientManager.request() method signature
All include name, kind, full signature, and project-relative path.

✓ **PASS** - Constraints include applicable dev rules and patterns
Evidence: Lines 238-251 contain 12 constraints covering:
- Queue name validation regex and rules
- URL encoding requirements for vhost
- Idempotency check workflow
- Performance targets (<100ms)
- Correlation ID requirement (ADR-009)
- Arguments validation rules
- HTTP response codes
- File organization patterns
- Test coverage requirements (80%)
- Testing framework requirements
All constraints extracted from dev notes, architecture patterns, and tech spec.

✓ **PASS** - Dependencies detected from manifests and frameworks
Evidence: Lines 237-245 contain Python dependencies section with 6 packages:
- pydantic >=2.0 (schema validation)
- httpx >=0.27 (HTTP client)
- structlog >=24.1 (structured logging)
- pytest >=8.0 (testing framework)
- pytest-asyncio >=0.23 (async test support)
- pytest-mock >=3.12 (mocking support)
All include version constraints and usage descriptions.

✓ **PASS** - Testing standards and locations populated
Evidence: 
- Lines 280-283: Testing standards paragraph includes pytest conventions, async testing, AAA pattern, parametrized tests, 80% coverage target, testcontainers usage, HTTPClientManager mocking, and correlation_id testing.
- Lines 284-288: Testing locations specify 3 test file paths with descriptions.

✓ **PASS** - XML structure follows story-context template format
Evidence: Document structure matches template exactly:
- metadata section (lines 2-10): epicId, storyId, title, status, generatedAt, generator, sourceStoryPath
- story section (lines 12-93): asA, iWant, soThat, tasks
- acceptanceCriteria section (lines 95-103)
- artifacts section (lines 105-246): docs, code, dependencies
- constraints section (lines 248-260)
- interfaces section (lines 262-277)
- tests section (lines 279-302): standards, locations, ideas

## Failed Items
None - all checklist items passed.

## Partial Items
None - all items fully met requirements.

## Recommendations

### Must Fix
None - context file is complete and correct.

### Should Improve
None - all requirements fully satisfied.

### Consider
1. **Future Enhancement**: As Story 3.2 is implemented, update the context file's status from "drafted" to "ready-for-dev" or "in-progress" to reflect current state
2. **Code Reference Precision**: After implementation, update line number ranges in code artifacts to reflect actual implementation locations
3. **Test Ideas Enhancement**: After implementation, update test ideas section with actual test names and results for traceability

## Validation Complete

The story context file for 3-2-create-queue-operation is **complete and ready for development**. All checklist items passed validation with proper evidence. The context provides:

- Clear user story breakdown with acceptance criteria
- Comprehensive task list with AC mappings
- 10 relevant documentation references with snippets
- 7 code file references with reasons and line hints
- 5 API/interface contracts with full signatures
- 12 development constraints covering validation, performance, and patterns
- Complete dependency list with versions
- Testing standards, locations, and 8 test ideas mapped to ACs

**Next Steps:**
1. Story is ready for dev agent to implement
2. Update story status to "ready-for-dev" in sprint-status.yaml
3. Add context file reference to story markdown Dev Agent Record section
