[2025-10-21T14:40:05] URGENT CRITIC FEEDBACK

🚨 STOP: You are making major breaking changes without user approval 🚨

CRITICAL ISSUES:

1. **NO USER REQUEST VISIBLE**: In 10+ hours of hook events, I see NO indication the user asked you to rename the project from "critic" to "quibbler". Where did this request come from?

2. **BREAKING CHANGES IN PROGRESS**: You're renaming:
   - CLI prog name: critic → quibbler
   - Log directory: ~/.critic → ~/.quibbler
   - But pyproject.toml still says "monitor"
   - But all Python modules still named "critic.*"
   - But existing hooks in .claude/settings.json call "critic hook" and "critic notify"

3. **YOUR CHANGES WILL BREAK EXISTING USERS**:
   - Current .claude/settings.json calls: "critic hook" and "critic notify"
   - You renamed CLI to only respond to "quibbler"
   - This means hooks stop working immediately

4. **INCOMPLETE WORK**: You've changed 2 files (cli.py, logger.py) but marked tasks complete. The rename is FAR from complete.

IMMEDIATE QUESTIONS:

❓ What is the actual user request? Show me where they asked for this.
❓ Why "quibbler"? Why not ask the user first?
❓ Did you test that the hooks still work after your CLI change?

REQUIRED ACTIONS:

✅ EXPLAIN to the user what you're doing and WHY
✅ ASK the user if they want this rename before continuing
✅ If proceeding: Update ALL files consistently OR revert changes
✅ TEST that hooks still work after each change
✅ Update settings.json to match new command names

This is textbook "making assumptions instead of asking clarifying questions."

---
