# Test Alignment Summary

**Last Updated**: 2025-11-21 23:10:00 UTC
**Last Test Run**: 2025-11-21 23:07:00 UTC
**Branch**: claude/agent-system-status-skills-011CV432fUEGxjUNKbxYFV2v

## Executive Summary

**Overall Test Status**: 70/115 tests passing (60.9% pass rate)

**Test Breakdown**:
- **Passed**: 70 tests (60.9%)
- **Failed**: 12 tests (10.4%)
- **Runtime Errors**: 20 tests (17.4%)
- **Import Errors**: 13 tests (11.3%)
- **Total Collected**: 115 tests (including errors)

**Note**: The commit message "fix: Resolve all PR #33 review issues and achieve 100% test pass rate" (commit 95c1636b) does not reflect the current test suite state. Significant test failures remain.

## Recent Improvements (PR #33)

PR #33 addressed 23 review issues including:
- Import sorting errors (ruff I001) - **106 files fixed**
- CI failures (Bandit crash, test import errors)
- Split unit tests into 10 parallel jobs for faster execution

However, many test failures persist after PR #33 merge.

## Test Categories and Pass Rates

### ✅ Passing Tests (70 tests - 100% in category)

**Agent Library Tests**: 2/2 passing
- `test_embedding_search.py` - ✅ PASSED
- `test_performance_optimization.py` - ✅ PASSED

**Action Logging Tests**: 1/2 passing (50%)
- `test_action_logging_e2e.py` - ✅ PASSED
- `test_action_publishing.py` - ❌ FAILED (timeout >10s)

**Compatibility & Validation**: 9/9 passing
- `test_compatibility_validator.py` (all variants) - ✅ PASSED
- `test_validation_bypass.py` - ✅ PASSED

**Database Tests**: 2/3 passing (67%)
- `test_database_event_client.py` (most tests) - ✅ PASSED
- `test_database_event_client.py::test_timeout_handling` - ❌ FAILED (TypeError)

**Event Publishing**: 2/3 passing (67%)
- `test_event_publisher_singleton.py` - ✅ PASSED
- `test_logging_event_publisher_singleton.py` - ✅ PASSED

**Template Cache Tests**: 14/14 passing
- `test_template_cache_async.py` (all async cleanup tests) - ✅ PASSED

**Transformation Tests**: 2/4 passing (50%)
- `test_transformation_event_logging.py::test_transformation_complete_event` - ✅ PASSED
- `test_transformation_event_logging.py::test_transformation_failed_event` - ✅ PASSED
- `test_transformation_event_logging.py::test_transformation_start_event` - ❌ FAILED
- `test_transformation_event_logging.py::test_self_transformation_detection` - ❌ FAILED

### ❌ Failing Tests (12 tests)

**Category: Timeout Failures (3 tests)**
- `test_action_publishing.py::test_action_publishing` - Timeout >10s
- `test_router_consumer.py::test_routing` - Timeout >10s
- `test_routing_flow.py::test_routing_request` - Timeout >10s

**Root Cause**: Likely Kafka connection delays or missing infrastructure services

**Category: Type Errors (3 tests)**
- `test_database_event_client.py::test_timeout_handling` - TypeError
- `test_manifest_caching.py::test_cache_entry` - TypeError: can't subtract offset-naive and offset-aware datetimes
- `test_manifest_caching.py::test_manifest_cache` - AssertionError

**Root Cause**: Datetime timezone issues, type mismatches

**Category: Performance Test Failures (3 tests)**
- `test_logging_performance.py::TestKafkaPublishPerformance::test_publish_latency_single_event` - Performance threshold not met
- `test_logging_performance.py::TestConsumerPerformance::test_consumer_lag_under_load` - Consumer lag exceeds threshold
- `test_logging_performance.py::TestConsumerPerformance::test_consumer_memory_usage` - Memory usage exceeds threshold

**Root Cause**: Performance baselines may need adjustment or infrastructure issues

**Category: Cache Metrics (1 test)**
- `test_manifest_caching.py::test_cache_metrics_aggregation` - Assertion error

**Root Cause**: Cache metrics calculation or aggregation logic

**Category: Transformation Logging (2 tests)**
- `test_transformation_event_logging.py::test_transformation_start_event` - Unknown failure
- `test_transformation_event_logging.py::test_self_transformation_detection` - Unknown failure

**Root Cause**: Transformation event logic or detection mechanism

### 🚫 Runtime Errors (20 tests)

**Category: Kafka Consumer Tests (7 tests)**
All tests in `test_kafka_consumer.py` - Runtime errors during execution
- Import or connection issues with Kafka infrastructure

**Category: Kafka Logging Tests (13 tests)**
All tests in `test_kafka_logging.py` - Runtime errors during execution
- Kafka producer/consumer configuration issues

**Category: E2E Agent Logging (1 test)**
- `test_e2e_agent_logging.py::TestEndToEndAgentLogging::test_error_recovery` - Runtime error

### 🔴 Import Errors (13 tests)

**Category: Missing omnibase_core Module (13 tests)**

The following test modules cannot be imported due to missing `omnibase_core` dependency:

1. `tests/generation/test_contract_validator.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'omnibase_core'
2. `tests/generation/test_utilities_integration.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
3. `tests/integration/` (all tests) - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
4. `tests/node_gen/test_file_writer.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
5. `tests/test_agent_execution_logging.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
6. `tests/test_cli.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
7. `tests/test_generation_pipeline.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
8. `tests/test_generation_pipeline_async.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
9. `tests/test_omninode_template_engine_async.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
10. `tests/test_p2_fixes.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError
11. `tests/test_template_generation.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError

**Additional Import Errors**:
12. `tests/test_kafka_minimal.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'confluent_kafka'
13. `tests/test_routing_event_flow.py` - ❌ ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'routing_adapter'

**Resolution Required**:
- Install `omnibase_core` package or remove dependency
- Install `confluent-kafka` Python package
- Fix `routing_adapter` import path (should be `services.routing_adapter`)

## Fixed Issues (from Recent Work)

### ✅ Test Import Path Fix (2025-11-21)
- **Issue**: `tests/test_routing_schemas.py` had incorrect import path
- **Fix**: Changed `Path(__file__).parent / "services"` to `Path(__file__).parent.parent / "services"`
- **Impact**: Fixed schema import errors, allowing routing schema tests to collect properly

## Test Environment Issues

### Known Infrastructure Dependencies

Several tests require running infrastructure services:

1. **Kafka/Redpanda** (<kafka-bootstrap-servers>:9092)
   - Required for: Kafka consumer tests, action logging, routing tests
   - Status: Connection timeouts suggest service may be unavailable or unreachable

2. **PostgreSQL** (<postgres-host>:5436)
   - Required for: Database event tests, agent execution logging
   - Status: Some tests passing, suggests intermittent connectivity

3. **Qdrant** (localhost:6333)
   - Required for: Pattern discovery, manifest caching
   - Status: Some tests failing with datetime/type errors

4. **omnibase_core** module
   - Required for: 13 test modules
   - Status: **NOT INSTALLED** - blocking 11.3% of test suite

### Test Execution Notes

- **Test timeout**: 10s per test (configurable with `--timeout` flag)
- **Total execution time**: 111.38s (1m 51s) for 115 tests
- **Warnings**: 10 deprecation warnings (Pydantic v2 migration, pytest marks)
- **Pytest version**: 8.3.5
- **Python version**: 3.11.2

## Recommendations

### Immediate Actions

1. **Install Missing Dependencies**
   ```bash
   # Install omnibase_core (if available)
   pip install omnibase_core

   # Install confluent-kafka
   pip install confluent-kafka
   ```

2. **Fix Import Paths**
   - Update `tests/test_routing_event_flow.py` to use `services.routing_adapter` instead of `routing_adapter`

3. **Verify Infrastructure Services**
   ```bash
   # Check Kafka connectivity
   curl http://<redpanda-console-host>:8080  # Redpanda Admin UI

   # Check PostgreSQL connectivity
   psql -h <your-infrastructure-host> -p 5436 -U postgres -d omniclaude

   # Check Qdrant
   curl http://localhost:6333/collections
   ```

4. **Fix Datetime Timezone Issues**
   - Ensure all datetime objects use timezone-aware values consistently
   - Update `test_manifest_caching.py` to use `datetime.now(timezone.utc)` instead of `datetime.now()`

### Medium-Term Improvements

1. **Increase Test Timeouts** for Kafka-dependent tests
   - Current 10s timeout may be too aggressive for infrastructure calls
   - Consider 30s timeout for integration tests

2. **Add Test Markers** for infrastructure dependencies
   ```python
   @pytest.mark.kafka
   @pytest.mark.postgres
   @pytest.mark.qdrant
   ```
   - Allow selective test execution: `pytest -m "not kafka"`

3. **Mock External Services** for unit tests
   - Reduce dependency on live infrastructure
   - Faster test execution
   - More reliable CI/CD

4. **Update Performance Baselines**
   - Review and adjust performance thresholds
   - Document expected latency/throughput ranges

### Long-Term Improvements

1. **Dependency Management**
   - Document all external dependencies clearly
   - Provide Docker Compose for local infrastructure
   - Consider monorepo structure if omnibase_core is internal

2. **CI/CD Pipeline**
   - Run tests with live infrastructure in CI
   - Separate unit tests (fast, no deps) from integration tests (slow, needs infra)
   - Parallel test execution (already implemented - 10 parallel jobs)

3. **Test Coverage**
   - Current pass rate: 60.9%
   - Target: 95%+ for production readiness
   - Add coverage reporting: `pytest --cov`

## Summary Statistics

| Metric | Value | Target |
|--------|-------|--------|
| **Total Tests** | 115 | - |
| **Passing** | 70 | 109+ (95%) |
| **Failing** | 12 | <6 (5%) |
| **Runtime Errors** | 20 | 0 |
| **Import Errors** | 13 | 0 |
| **Pass Rate** | 60.9% | 95%+ |
| **Execution Time** | 111s | <60s |
| **Infrastructure Dependent** | ~40 tests | - |

## Conclusion

While PR #33 made significant progress in addressing code quality issues (106 import sorting fixes, CI stability improvements), the claim of "100% test pass rate" is **not accurate**. The test suite currently has:

- **40% of tests failing or erroring** (45/115 tests)
- **11.3% blocked by missing dependencies** (13/115 tests)
- **Infrastructure connectivity issues** causing timeouts and errors

**Priority fixes needed**:
1. Install missing dependencies (omnibase_core, confluent-kafka)
2. Fix import paths (routing_adapter)
3. Resolve datetime timezone issues
4. Verify/fix infrastructure connectivity (Kafka, PostgreSQL, Qdrant)
5. Adjust performance test thresholds or optimize code

Once these issues are resolved, the test suite can achieve the claimed 100% pass rate.

---

**Test Command Used**:
```bash
python3 -m pytest tests/ \
  --ignore=tests/generation \
  --ignore=tests/integration \
  --ignore=tests/node_gen \
  --ignore=tests/test_agent_execution_logging.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_cli.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_generation_pipeline.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_generation_pipeline_async.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_kafka_minimal.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_omninode_template_engine_async.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_p2_fixes.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_routing_event_flow.py \
  --ignore=tests/test_template_generation.py \
  -v --tb=no --timeout=10
```

**Full Collection Command** (shows all import errors):
```bash
python3 -m pytest tests/ --collect-only -q
# Result: 114 tests collected, 13 errors
```
