# Patent Valuation Complete - US10958080B2

## VALUATION SUMMARY

**Patent:** US10958080B2 - Method and Apparatus for Transmitting Wireless Power
**Assignee:** Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
**Valuation Method:** Income Method (DCF)
**Valuation Date:** November 16, 2025

### VALUATION RESULTS

- **Conservative NPV:** $119,422
- **Base Case NPV:** $340,413 (PRIMARY VALUATION)
- **Bull Case NPV:** $1,113,306
- **Recommended Range:** $119,422 - $1,113,306

### KEY FINDINGS

**Commercialization Status:** FULLY COMMERCIALIZED (100% probability)
- Samsung SmartThings Station (CES 2023)
- Samsung Wireless Charger Trio (EP-P6300)
- Porsche 11kW Wireless Charging System (2026 Cayenne Electric)

**Patent Strength:** 86/100 (86th Percentile - EXCELLENT)
- 300 forward citations (Top 5% in industry)
- HIGH blocking potential
- STRONG claim breadth and quality
- 6-member patent family
- 16 years remaining life

**Market Opportunity:**
- TAM: $71.86 million
- SAM: $12.72 million
- Primary Markets: EV Charging ($47.61B, 34.1% CAGR), Consumer Electronics ($2-5B), Smart Home Hubs

**Financial Metrics:**
- Discount Rate: 12.81% (WACC 4.81% + 8% risk premium)
- IP Contribution Factor: 0.47 (47%)
- Profit Margin: 25%
- Royalty Rate: 3%

**Risk Assessment:** LOW (8% overall risk premium)
- Mature technology (TRL 8-9)
- Strong commercial validation
- Excellent patent quality
- Credible assignee (Samsung)

### STRATEGIC RECOMMENDATIONS

1. **Active Licensing Strategy:** Pursue automotive OEM licensing (Porsche precedent validates market)
2. **Enforcement Consideration:** High blocking potential with 300 forward citations supports enforcement actions if needed
3. **Portfolio Integration:** Leverage 6-member patent family for enhanced negotiating position
4. **Geographic Expansion:** International filings (EP, CN, JP) could multiply TAM by 3-5x
5. **Segment Expansion:** Opportunities in medical devices (FDA approval pathway) and industrial IoT

### ALL DELIVERABLES SAVED

Complete analysis saved to: `/home/rezaho/research_projects/Multi-agent_AI_Learning/examples/01_IP_Valuation/results/20251116_193256/`

**Generated Reports (11 files):**
1. 01_patent_data.md - USPTO patent data collection
2. 02_patent_analysis.md - Technology and claims analysis
3. 03_application_research.md - Commercial applications research
4. 04_market_sizing.md - TAM/SAM/SOM bottom-up analysis
5. 05_financial_data.md - Industry benchmarks and WACC
6. 06_patent_strength.md - Patent quality and strength scoring
7. 07_attribution_estimate.md - IP contribution factor calculation
8. 08_commercialization_assessment.md - TRL/CRL and commercialization probability
9. 09_discount_rate.md - Discount rate calculation
10. 10_valuation_calculation.md - DCF valuation with sensitivity analysis
11. 11_final_report.md - **COMPREHENSIVE FINAL REPORT** (16 sections, 35+ tables)

### DATA SOURCES (All Free)

- USPTO/Google Patents (patent data)
- EPO Patent Database (family information)
- SEC EDGAR (financial data)
- Damodaran Industry Data (January 2025 - WACC, margins)
- Commercial product validation (Samsung, Porsche press releases)
- Market research (publicly available reports)

### QUALITY ASSURANCE

✅ All assumptions documented (30+ items with confidence ratings)
✅ All data sources cited (15 primary sources)
✅ Bottom-up market sizing methodology applied
✅ Portfolio attribution addressed (47% contribution factor)
✅ Commercialization probability quantified (100% - fully commercialized)
✅ Blocking potential assessed (HIGH - 300 forward citations)
✅ Sensitivity analysis completed (±20% variations)
✅ Professional report format with executive summary

**Valuation complete and ready for portfolio management decision-making.**