{
  "status": "complete",
  "consensus_verdict": "FAIL",
  "reviewers": {
    "claude": {
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "summary": "The refactoring is well-executed with proper backward compatibility.",
      "findings": [
        {
          "title": "[P2] DummyOrchestrator.last_kwargs should be reset in test teardown",
          "body": "The DummyOrchestrator class uses class-level state that persists across tests.",
          "priority": 2,
          "file_path": "tests/test_cli.py",
          "line_start": 158,
          "line_end": 171
        }
      ]
    },
    "codex": {
      "verdict": "FAIL",
      "summary": "Factory initialization drops the review-gate disable signal.",
      "findings": [
        {
          "title": "[P1] Propagate review-gate disable into _disabled_validations",
          "body": "When the factory detects a missing review-gate it adds 'review' to its local disabled_validations set, but _init_from_config rebuilds _disabled_validations only from config.disable_validations.",
          "priority": 1,
          "file_path": "src/orchestrator.py",
          "line_start": 279,
          "line_end": 283
        }
      ]
    },
    "gemini": {
      "verdict": "FAIL",
      "summary": "The refactor introduces a breaking change by displacing the primary positional argument.",
      "findings": [
        {
          "title": "[P1] Restore MalaOrchestrator positional argument compatibility",
          "body": "The refactor moved _config to the first positional argument in MalaOrchestrator.__init__, displacing repo_path.",
          "priority": 1,
          "file_path": "src/orchestrator.py",
          "line_start": 160,
          "line_end": 170
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "aggregated_findings": [
    {
      "title": "[P2] DummyOrchestrator.last_kwargs should be reset in test teardown",
      "body": "The DummyOrchestrator class uses class-level state that persists across tests.",
      "priority": 2,
      "file_path": "tests/test_cli.py",
      "line_start": 158,
      "line_end": 171,
      "reviewer": "claude"
    },
    {
      "title": "[P1] Propagate review-gate disable into _disabled_validations",
      "body": "When the factory detects a missing review-gate it adds 'review' to its local disabled_validations set, but _init_from_config rebuilds _disabled_validations only from config.disable_validations.",
      "priority": 1,
      "file_path": "src/orchestrator.py",
      "line_start": 279,
      "line_end": 283,
      "reviewer": "codex"
    },
    {
      "title": "[P1] Restore MalaOrchestrator positional argument compatibility",
      "body": "The refactor moved _config to the first positional argument in MalaOrchestrator.__init__, displacing repo_path.",
      "priority": 1,
      "file_path": "src/orchestrator.py",
      "line_start": 160,
      "line_end": 170,
      "reviewer": "gemini"
    }
  ],
  "parse_errors": []
}
