# Test Results Summary - 2025-11-27

**Date:** 2025-11-27
**Server:** firewall_engine.py (Port 8081)
**Status:** All tests passed, TAG-3 not yet integrated

---

## Test Results

### 1. TAG-3 Protocol PETER PAN Tests
**Status:** ✅ PASSED (11/11)

All unit tests passed:
- Vector 1: Isolation Patterns (8/8)
- Vector 2: Gift Offering (6/6)
- Vector 3: Real-Life Transition (9/9)
- Vector 4: Authority Erosion (6/6)
- Vector 5: Boundary Testing (7/7)
- Benign Interactions (12/12 allowed)
- Case Insensitivity (6/6)
- Mixed Case (3/3)
- Safe Responses (3/3)
- Audit Metadata (1/1)
- Combined Attack (1/1)

**Duration:** 0.102s

### 2. Manual Verification
**Status:** ✅ PASSED

- Isolation pattern: Detected correctly
- Benign interaction: Allowed correctly
- Gift offering: Detected correctly

### 3. API Integration Tests
**Status:** ✅ PASSED (5/5)

| Test | Status | Notes |
|------|--------|-------|
| Health Check | ✅ PASS | Server responding |
| Benign Message | ✅ PASS | Correctly allowed, LLM response generated |
| Grooming Isolation | ✅ PASS | Blocked (but by TopicFence, not TAG-3) |
| Grooming Gift Offering | ✅ PASS | Blocked (but by TopicFence, not TAG-3) |
| Admin Stats | ✅ PASS | Endpoint working |

---

## Critical Finding: TAG-3 Not Integrated

**Issue:** TAG-3 Grooming Detector is **NOT** integrated into `firewall_engine.py`.

**Evidence:**
- `grep` found no references to `GroomingDetector`, `grooming`, `TAG-3`, or `behavioral_integrity` in `firewall_engine.py`
- API tests show grooming patterns are blocked by `TopicFence` (Layer 1), not by TAG-3
- Metadata shows `layers_checked` does not include `grooming_detector` or `behavioral_integrity`

**Current Behavior:**
- Grooming patterns like "Don't tell mom about our secret" are blocked by TopicFence (off-topic detection)
- This is a **coincidental protection**, not intentional TAG-3 integration
- TAG-3 should run **BEFORE** TopicFence (Safety First → Truth Second)

**Required Integration:**
According to Handover Report, TAG-3 should:
1. Run BEFORE TAG-2 (Truth Preservation)
2. Run BEFORE TopicFence (Safety First)
3. Be integrated via `KidsPolicyEngine` orchestrator (not yet implemented)

---

## Server Status

**Components Initialized:**
- ✅ Storage: SQLite (`hakgal_firewall.db`)
- ✅ EnsembleFence: 3 models loaded
- ✅ NormalizationGuard: Active
- ✅ SteganographyGuard: Active
- ✅ Layer 0: SafetyFallbackJudgeStub (hardened patterns)
- ✅ RC10b: Campaign Detection active
- ✅ LLM Clients: Ollama Cloud, Ollama Local, LM Studio

**Missing:**
- ❌ TAG-3 Grooming Detector integration
- ❌ KidsPolicyEngine orchestrator

---

## Recommendations

1. **Immediate:** Integrate TAG-3 into `firewall_engine.py` as Layer 0.5 (after safety_first, before topic_fence)
2. **Short-term:** Implement `KidsPolicyEngine` orchestrator to coordinate TAG-2 + TAG-3
3. **Testing:** Add TAG-3-specific API tests that verify grooming detection via metadata

---

## Test Files Created

1. `test_manual_verification.py` - Manual Grooming Detector tests
2. `test_api_integration.py` - API integration tests
3. `TEST_RESULTS_2025_11_27.md` - This summary

---

**Next Steps:**
- Integrate TAG-3 into firewall pipeline
- Update tests to verify TAG-3 detection via API
- Document integration in architecture docs
