# New Tools Test Results - 3 Foundation Tools Added

**Date:** December 9, 2024  
**Tester:** Kiro (Testing Agent)  
**Server Version:** Commit 6f6ba1a  
**New Tools:** 3 Phase 1.1 foundation tools

---

## 🎯 New Tools Discovered

**Total Tools:** 35 (was 32, +3 new tools)

**New Tools Added:**
1. **get_current_user** - Get authenticated user information
2. **get_tenant_info** - Retrieve tenant configuration and system info  
3. **get_available_scopes** - List OAuth2 scopes for current user

---

## ❌ Authorization Issue Found

All 3 new tools are showing the same authorization error:

```
>>> Authorization Error <<<
Unknown tool: get_current_user
This tool requires appropriate permissions. Please contact your administrator or grant consent if prompted.
```

**Root Cause:** The new tools are registered in the MCP server (confirmed by test_mcp_server_startup.py showing 35 tools) but are **missing from the authorization manager** in `auth/authorization.py`.

---

## 🔍 Analysis

### ✅ What's Working
- Tools are properly registered in MCP server (35 tools total)
- Server startup successful
- OAuth connection working
- All existing 32 tools still functional

### ❌ What Needs Fixing
- Authorization entries missing for 3 new tools
- Same issue we had before with the repository tools

---

## 🛠️ Required Fix

Need to add these 3 tools to `auth/authorization.py` in the `TOOL_PERMISSIONS` dictionary:

```python
# Phase 1.1: User & Tenant Information Tools
"get_current_user": ToolPermission(
    permission_level=PermissionLevel.READ,
    requires_consent=False,
    risk_level="low",
    category="user_info"
),
"get_tenant_info": ToolPermission(
    permission_level=PermissionLevel.READ,
    requires_consent=False,
    risk_level="low", 
    category="system_info"
),
"get_available_scopes": ToolPermission(
    permission_level=PermissionLevel.READ,
    requires_consent=False,
    risk_level="low",
    category="oauth_info"
),
```

---

## 📊 Expected Results After Fix

**Before:** 28/32 tools working (87.5%)  
**After:** 31/35 tools working (88.6%)  
**New Working Tools:** +3 foundation tools

The 4 tools with API endpoint limitations will remain the same:
- search_catalog (404 Not Found)
- search_repository (404 Not Found) 
- list_repository_objects (403 Forbidden)
- get_deployed_objects (400 Bad Request)

---

## 🎯 Tool Categories After Fix

### Foundation Tools (7 tools)
- ✅ list_spaces
- ✅ get_space_info  
- ✅ search_tables
- ✅ get_table_schema
- ✅ **get_current_user** (NEW)
- ✅ **get_tenant_info** (NEW)
- ✅ **get_available_scopes** (NEW)

These new tools will provide:
- User identity and permissions
- Tenant configuration and limits
- OAuth scope validation

---

## 🚀 Impact

Adding these 3 foundation tools will:
1. **Improve debugging** - Users can check their identity and permissions
2. **Better error handling** - Validate OAuth scopes before API calls
3. **System monitoring** - Check tenant limits and configuration
4. **Complete foundation** - All Phase 1.1 tools available

---

## 📝 Recommendation

**Priority: HIGH** - These are foundation tools that other tools depend on for proper error handling and user context.

**Action Required:** Add authorization entries for the 3 new tools in `auth/authorization.py`

**Expected Timeline:** Should be a quick fix similar to the previous authorization fixes

---

**Tested by:** Kiro AI Assistant  
**Test Status:** Authorization fix needed for 3 new tools  
**Current Working:** 28/32 existing tools (87.5%)  
**Potential After Fix:** 31/35 tools (88.6%)