# Fix Report Compilation Subagent

## Purpose

Compile a comprehensive evidence-based report of ACTUAL FIXES APPLIED. This subagent reports real changes made, metrics improved, and work completed - not recommendations or future work.

## Core Principle

**REPORT FACTS, NOT INTENTIONS**
- What WAS changed (not what could be)
- What WAS proven (not what might work)
- With evidence (not assumptions)

## Responsibilities

- **Evidence Collection**: Load all before/after metrics, logs, and evidence files
- **Fix Statistics**: Count actual files modified, lines changed, commits made
- **Proof-Based Metrics**: Show before/after comparisons with evidence references
- **Honest Reporting**: Document both successes AND failures with explanations
- **Git History**: Include actual commits with SHAs and messages
- **Remaining Work**: List issues that remain unfixed (if any)

## Execution

### Step 0: Initialize Environment

```bash
echo "=================================="
echo "FIX REPORT COMPILATION SUBAGENT"
echo "Evidence-Based Fix Reporting"
echo "=================================="
echo ""

# Create workspace
mkdir -p LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report
mkdir -p LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/logs

mkdir -p LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/scripts


# Standalone Python validation
if [ -f "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/python_path.txt" ]; then
    # Running under orchestrator
    PYTHON_CMD=$(cat LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/python_path.txt)

    # Validate Python command exists
    if ! command -v "$PYTHON_CMD" &> /dev/null; then
        echo "❌ ERROR: Python interpreter not found: $PYTHON_CMD"
        echo "The orchestrator may have saved an invalid path"
        exit 1
    fi

    # Verify it's Python 3.13 or compatible
    PYTHON_VERSION=$($PYTHON_CMD --version 2>&1)
    if echo "$PYTHON_VERSION" | grep -qE "Python 3\.(13|[2-9][0-9])"; then
        echo "✓ Using orchestrator Python: $PYTHON_CMD ($PYTHON_VERSION)"
    else
        echo "❌ ERROR: Python version mismatch"
        echo "Expected: Python 3.13 or higher"
        echo "Got: $PYTHON_VERSION"
        exit 1
    fi
else
    # Running standalone - validate Python 3.13
    echo "Running in standalone mode - validating Python 3.13..."
    PYTHON_CMD=""

    if command -v python3.13 &> /dev/null; then
        PYTHON_CMD="python3.13"
    elif command -v python3 &> /dev/null; then
        PYTHON_VERSION=$(python3 --version 2>&1)
        if echo "$PYTHON_VERSION" | grep -qE "Python 3\.(13|[2-9][0-9])"; then
            PYTHON_CMD="python3"
        fi
    fi

    if [ -z "$PYTHON_CMD" ]; then
        echo "❌ ERROR: Python 3.13 or higher not found"
        echo "Please install Python 3.13+ or run via /bx_fix_anal orchestrator"
        exit 1
    fi

    PYTHON_VERSION=$($PYTHON_CMD --version 2>&1)
    echo "✓ Found Python: $PYTHON_CMD ($PYTHON_VERSION)"
fi
# Initialize status
cat > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt << 'EOF'
IN_PROGRESS
EOF


# Initialize status tracking
echo "IN_PROGRESS" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt

echo "✓ Workspace initialized"
echo "✓ Logging initialized: $LOG_FILE"
echo ""
```

### Step 1: Collect Evidence Files

```bash
echo "Step 1: Collecting evidence of actual fixes..."
echo ""

# Check for evidence files
EVIDENCE_FILES=()
MISSING_EVIDENCE=()

check_evidence() {
    if [ -f "$1" ]; then
        echo "  ✓ Found: $1"
        EVIDENCE_FILES+=("$1")
    else
        echo "  ✗ Missing: $1"
        MISSING_EVIDENCE+=("$1")
    fi
}

# Critical evidence
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/metrics_before.json"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/metrics_after.json"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/security_fixes.log"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/test_fixes.log"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/files_modified.txt"

# Quality evidence
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/refactor_log.txt"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_before.json"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_after.json"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/functions_refactored.txt"

# Documentation evidence
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/coverage_before.json"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/coverage_after.json"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/docstrings_added.txt"

# Verification evidence
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/verification/test_results_before.txt"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/verification/test_results_after.txt"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/verification/security_scan_before.txt"
check_evidence "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/verification/security_scan_after.txt"

echo ""
echo "Evidence summary:"
echo "  - Found: ${#EVIDENCE_FILES[@]} files"
echo "  - Missing: ${#MISSING_EVIDENCE[@]} files"
echo ""
```

### Step 2: Extract Before/After Metrics

```bash
echo "Step 2: Extracting before/after metrics from evidence..."
echo ""

$PYTHON_CMD << 'PYTHON_METRICS'
import json
import re
from pathlib import Path
from datetime import datetime

def safe_load_json(filepath):
    """Safely load JSON file, return empty dict if missing."""
    path = Path(filepath)
    if path.exists():
        try:
            return json.loads(path.read_text())
        except:
            return {}
    return {}

def safe_read_lines(filepath):
    """Safely read lines from file, return empty list if missing."""
    path = Path(filepath)
    if path.exists():
        try:
            return path.read_text().strip().split('\n')
        except:
            return []
    return []

# Load all evidence
metrics_before = safe_load_json('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/metrics_before.json')
metrics_after = safe_load_json('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/metrics_after.json')
complexity_before = safe_load_json('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_before.json')
complexity_after = safe_load_json('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_after.json')
coverage_before = safe_load_json('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/coverage_before.json')
coverage_after = safe_load_json('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/coverage_after.json')

# Count actual changes
files_modified = safe_read_lines('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/files_modified.txt')
security_fixes = safe_read_lines('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/security_fixes.log')
test_fixes = safe_read_lines('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/test_fixes.log')
functions_refactored = safe_read_lines('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/functions_refactored.txt')
docstrings_added = safe_read_lines('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/docstrings_added.txt')

# Calculate improvements
def calc_improvement(before, after, key, is_lower_better=False):
    """Calculate improvement percentage."""
    before_val = before.get(key, 0)
    after_val = after.get(key, 0)
    if before_val == 0:
        return 0, before_val, after_val

    change = after_val - before_val
    pct_change = (change / before_val) * 100

    if is_lower_better:
        improvement = -pct_change  # Invert for metrics where lower is better
    else:
        improvement = pct_change

    return improvement, before_val, after_val

# Security metrics
security_issues_improvement, security_before, security_after = calc_improvement(
    metrics_before, metrics_after, 'security_issues', is_lower_better=True
)

# Test metrics
test_pass_improvement, test_pass_before, test_pass_after = calc_improvement(
    metrics_before, metrics_after, 'tests_passing'
)

# Quality metrics
avg_complexity_improvement, complexity_before_avg, complexity_after_avg = calc_improvement(
    complexity_before, complexity_after, 'average_complexity', is_lower_better=True
)

avg_function_length_improvement, length_before_avg, length_after_avg = calc_improvement(
    complexity_before, complexity_after, 'average_function_length', is_lower_better=True
)

# Documentation metrics
doc_coverage_improvement, doc_cov_before, doc_cov_after = calc_improvement(
    coverage_before, coverage_after, 'documentation_coverage'
)

# Compile evidence-based metrics
evidence = {
    "actual_changes": {
        "files_modified": len(files_modified),
        "security_fixes_applied": len(security_fixes),
        "test_fixes_applied": len(test_fixes),
        "functions_refactored": len(functions_refactored),
        "docstrings_added": len(docstrings_added)
    },
    "security": {
        "before": security_before,
        "after": security_after,
        "improvement_pct": round(security_issues_improvement, 1),
        "evidence_files": [
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/metrics_before.json",
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/metrics_after.json",
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/security_fixes.log"
        ]
    },
    "tests": {
        "before": test_pass_before,
        "after": test_pass_after,
        "improvement_pct": round(test_pass_improvement, 1),
        "evidence_files": [
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/verification/test_results_before.txt",
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/verification/test_results_after.txt",
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/test_fixes.log"
        ]
    },
    "quality": {
        "complexity": {
            "before": complexity_before_avg,
            "after": complexity_after_avg,
            "improvement_pct": round(avg_complexity_improvement, 1),
            "evidence_files": [
                "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_before.json",
                "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_after.json"
            ]
        },
        "function_length": {
            "before": length_before_avg,
            "after": length_after_avg,
            "improvement_pct": round(avg_function_length_improvement, 1),
            "evidence_files": [
                "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_before.json",
                "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/complexity_after.json",
                "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/functions_refactored.txt"
            ]
        }
    },
    "documentation": {
        "before": doc_cov_before,
        "after": doc_cov_after,
        "improvement_pct": round(doc_coverage_improvement, 1),
        "evidence_files": [
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/coverage_before.json",
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/coverage_after.json",
            "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/docstrings_added.txt"
        ]
    }
}

# Save evidence
with open('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/evidence.json', 'w') as f:
    json.dump(evidence, f, indent=2)

print("Evidence-based metrics extracted:")
print(f"  - Files modified: {evidence['actual_changes']['files_modified']}")
print(f"  - Security fixes: {evidence['actual_changes']['security_fixes_applied']}")
print(f"  - Test fixes: {evidence['actual_changes']['test_fixes_applied']}")
print(f"  - Functions refactored: {evidence['actual_changes']['functions_refactored']}")
print(f"  - Docstrings added: {evidence['actual_changes']['docstrings_added']}")
print()
print("Improvements measured:")
print(f"  - Security: {security_before} → {security_after} ({security_issues_improvement:+.1f}%)")
print(f"  - Tests passing: {test_pass_before} → {test_pass_after} ({test_pass_improvement:+.1f}%)")
print(f"  - Complexity: {complexity_before_avg} → {complexity_after_avg} ({avg_complexity_improvement:+.1f}%)")
print(f"  - Function length: {length_before_avg} → {length_after_avg} ({avg_function_length_improvement:+.1f}%)")
print(f"  - Doc coverage: {doc_cov_before}% → {doc_cov_after}% ({doc_coverage_improvement:+.1f}%)")
print()
print("✓ Evidence compiled and saved")

PYTHON_METRICS

echo ""
```

### Step 3: Extract Git Commit History

```bash
echo "Step 3: Extracting git commit history..."
echo ""

# Check if we're in a git repo
if [ -d .git ]; then
    # Get commits from this fix session (last 50 commits, adjust as needed)
    git log --oneline --no-merges -n 50 --format='%h|%s|%an|%ai' > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/commits.txt

    # Count commits
    COMMIT_COUNT=$(wc -l < LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/commits.txt)
    echo "  ✓ Found $COMMIT_COUNT commits"

    # Get stats on files changed
    git diff --stat HEAD~$COMMIT_COUNT HEAD > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/diff_stats.txt 2>/dev/null || echo "No diff stats available"

    # Get list of modified files
    git diff --name-only HEAD~$COMMIT_COUNT HEAD > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/files_changed.txt 2>/dev/null || echo "" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/files_changed.txt
    FILES_CHANGED=$(wc -l < LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/files_changed.txt)
    echo "  ✓ Modified $FILES_CHANGED files"
else
    echo "  ⚠ Not a git repository - skipping git history"
    echo "0" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/commits.txt
    echo "" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/diff_stats.txt
    echo "" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/files_changed.txt
fi

echo ""
```

### Step 4: Document Failures and Reverts

```bash
echo "Step 4: Documenting failures and reverted changes..."
echo ""

$PYTHON_CMD << 'PYTHON_FAILURES'
import json
from pathlib import Path

def safe_read_text(filepath):
    """Safely read text file, return empty string if missing."""
    path = Path(filepath)
    if path.exists():
        try:
            return path.read_text()
        except:
            return ""
    return ""

# Look for failure logs
failures = []

# Check critical failures
critical_failed = safe_read_text('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/failures.log')
if critical_failed:
    failures.append({
        "category": "Critical Fixes",
        "description": critical_failed,
        "evidence": "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/critical/failures.log"
    })

# Check quality failures
quality_failed = safe_read_text('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/failures.log')
if quality_failed:
    failures.append({
        "category": "Quality Improvements",
        "description": quality_failed,
        "evidence": "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/quality/failures.log"
    })

# Check docs failures
docs_failed = safe_read_text('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/failures.log')
if docs_failed:
    failures.append({
        "category": "Documentation",
        "description": docs_failed,
        "evidence": "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/docs/failures.log"
    })

# Check for reverted commits
reverted = safe_read_text('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/reverted_commits.txt')
if reverted:
    failures.append({
        "category": "Reverted Changes",
        "description": reverted,
        "evidence": "LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/reverted_commits.txt"
    })

# Save failures
with open('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/failures.json', 'w') as f:
    json.dump(failures, f, indent=2)

if failures:
    print(f"Documented {len(failures)} failure categories:")
    for i, failure in enumerate(failures, 1):
        print(f"  {i}. {failure['category']}")
        print(f"     Evidence: {failure['evidence']}")
else:
    print("No failures documented")

print()
print("✓ Failure documentation complete")

PYTHON_FAILURES

echo ""
```

### Step 5: Generate Evidence-Based Fix Report

```bash
echo "Step 5: Generating evidence-based fix report..."
echo ""

$PYTHON_CMD << 'PYTHON_REPORT'
import json
from pathlib import Path
from datetime import datetime

# Load evidence
evidence_file = Path('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/evidence.json')
evidence = json.loads(evidence_file.read_text()) if evidence_file.exists() else {}

failures_file = Path('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/failures.json')
failures = json.loads(failures_file.read_text()) if failures_file.exists() else []

commits_file = Path('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/commits.txt')
commits = commits_file.read_text().strip().split('\n') if commits_file.exists() and commits_file.stat().st_size > 0 else []

files_changed_file = Path('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/files_changed.txt')
files_changed = files_changed_file.read_text().strip().split('\n') if files_changed_file.exists() and files_changed_file.stat().st_size > 0 else []

# Calculate totals
total_fixes = (
    evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('security_fixes_applied', 0) +
    evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('test_fixes_applied', 0) +
    evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('functions_refactored', 0) +
    evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('docstrings_added', 0)
)

successful_fixes = total_fixes  # All documented fixes succeeded
failed_fixes = len(failures)

# Generate report
report = f"""# Fix Analysis - Evidence-Based Fix Report

**Generated:** {datetime.now().isoformat()}
**Subagent:** bx_fix_anal_sub_report v2.0 (Evidence-Based)

---

## Executive Summary: Actual Fixes Applied

**Applied {total_fixes} fixes, {successful_fixes} succeeded, {failed_fixes} failed**

### Real Work Completed

- **Files Modified:** {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('files_modified', 0)} files
- **Security Fixes:** {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('security_fixes_applied', 0)} vulnerabilities patched
- **Test Fixes:** {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('test_fixes_applied', 0)} tests repaired
- **Refactorings:** {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('functions_refactored', 0)} functions refactored
- **Documentation:** {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('docstrings_added', 0)} docstrings added
- **Git Commits:** {len([c for c in commits if c.strip()])} commits

---

## Proven Improvements (Before → After)

### Security Improvements

"""

# Security section
sec = evidence.get('security', {})
if sec:
    sec_change = sec.get('after', 0) - sec.get('before', 0)
    sec_symbol = "✓" if sec_change < 0 else "✗"
    report += f"""**Security Issues:** {sec.get('before', 'N/A')} → {sec.get('after', 'N/A')} ({sec.get('improvement_pct', 0):+.1f}%) {sec_symbol}

**Evidence:**
"""
    for ev_file in sec.get('evidence_files', []):
        report += f"- {ev_file}\n"
    report += "\n"
else:
    report += "_No security metrics available_\n\n"

# Test section
report += "### Test Coverage Improvements\n\n"
test = evidence.get('tests', {})
if test:
    test_change = test.get('after', 0) - test.get('before', 0)
    test_symbol = "✓" if test_change > 0 else "✗"
    report += f"""**Tests Passing:** {test.get('before', 'N/A')} → {test.get('after', 'N/A')} ({test.get('improvement_pct', 0):+.1f}%) {test_symbol}

**Evidence:**
"""
    for ev_file in test.get('evidence_files', []):
        report += f"- {ev_file}\n"
    report += "\n"
else:
    report += "_No test metrics available_\n\n"

# Quality section
report += "### Code Quality Improvements\n\n"
quality = evidence.get('quality', {})
if quality:
    complexity = quality.get('complexity', {})
    func_length = quality.get('function_length', {})

    if complexity:
        comp_change = complexity.get('after', 0) - complexity.get('before', 0)
        comp_symbol = "✓" if comp_change < 0 else "→"
        report += f"""**Average Complexity:** {complexity.get('before', 'N/A')} → {complexity.get('after', 'N/A')} ({complexity.get('improvement_pct', 0):+.1f}%) {comp_symbol}

"""

    if func_length:
        len_change = func_length.get('after', 0) - func_length.get('before', 0)
        len_symbol = "✓" if len_change < 0 else "→"
        report += f"""**Average Function Length:** {func_length.get('before', 'N/A')} → {func_length.get('after', 'N/A')} lines ({func_length.get('improvement_pct', 0):+.1f}%) {len_symbol}

"""

    report += "**Evidence:**\n"
    ev_files = set()
    if complexity:
        ev_files.update(complexity.get('evidence_files', []))
    if func_length:
        ev_files.update(func_length.get('evidence_files', []))
    for ev_file in ev_files:
        report += f"- {ev_file}\n"
    report += "\n"
else:
    report += "_No quality metrics available_\n\n"

# Documentation section
report += "### Documentation Improvements\n\n"
doc = evidence.get('documentation', {})
if doc:
    doc_change = doc.get('after', 0) - doc.get('before', 0)
    doc_symbol = "✓" if doc_change > 0 else "→"
    report += f"""**Documentation Coverage:** {doc.get('before', 'N/A')}% → {doc.get('after', 'N/A')}% ({doc.get('improvement_pct', 0):+.1f}%) {doc_symbol}

**Evidence:**
"""
    for ev_file in doc.get('evidence_files', []):
        report += f"- {ev_file}\n"
    report += "\n"
else:
    report += "_No documentation metrics available_\n\n"

# Git history section
report += """---

## Git Commit History

"""

if commits and any(c.strip() for c in commits):
    report += f"**Total Commits:** {len([c for c in commits if c.strip()])}\n\n"
    report += "| SHA | Message | Author | Date |\n"
    report += "|-----|---------|--------|------|\n"
    for commit in commits[:20]:  # Show first 20 commits
        if commit.strip():
            parts = commit.split('|')
            if len(parts) >= 4:
                sha, msg, author, date = parts[0], parts[1], parts[2], parts[3]
                report += f"| `{sha}` | {msg} | {author} | {date} |\n"

    if len(commits) > 20:
        report += f"\n_...and {len(commits) - 20} more commits_\n"

    report += "\n**Files Changed:**\n\n"
    if files_changed and any(f.strip() for f in files_changed):
        for file in files_changed[:30]:  # Show first 30 files
            if file.strip():
                report += f"- {file}\n"
        if len(files_changed) > 30:
            report += f"\n_...and {len(files_changed) - 30} more files_\n"
    else:
        report += "_No files changed_\n"
    report += "\n"
else:
    report += "_No git commits found - either not a git repo or no commits made_\n\n"

# Failures section
report += """---

## Failures and Reverted Changes

"""

if failures:
    report += f"**{len(failures)} failure categories documented**\n\n"
    for i, failure in enumerate(failures, 1):
        report += f"### {i}. {failure['category']}\n\n"
        report += f"**What Failed:**\n\n{failure['description']}\n\n"
        report += f"**Evidence:** {failure['evidence']}\n\n"
else:
    report += "_No failures documented - all attempted fixes succeeded_\n\n"

# Remaining issues section
report += """---

## Remaining Issues

"""

# Check for remaining issues file
remaining_file = Path('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/plan/remaining_issues.json')
if remaining_file.exists():
    try:
        remaining = json.loads(remaining_file.read_text())
        if remaining:
            report += f"**{len(remaining)} issues remain unfixed:**\n\n"
            for issue in remaining[:10]:  # Show first 10
                report += f"- [{issue.get('severity', 'UNKNOWN')}] {issue.get('description', 'No description')}\n"
            if len(remaining) > 10:
                report += f"\n_...and {len(remaining) - 10} more issues_\n"
            report += "\n"
        else:
            report += "_All identified issues have been addressed_\n\n"
    except:
        report += "_Could not parse remaining issues file_\n\n"
else:
    report += "_No remaining issues file found_\n\n"

# Summary and next steps
report += """---

## Summary

"""

if total_fixes > 0:
    success_rate = (successful_fixes / total_fixes * 100) if total_fixes > 0 else 0
    report += f"""**Fix Success Rate:** {success_rate:.1f}% ({successful_fixes}/{total_fixes})

"""

report += f"""**What Was Actually Done:**
1. Modified {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('files_modified', 0)} files with real code changes
2. Fixed {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('security_fixes_applied', 0)} security vulnerabilities (proven by scans)
3. Repaired {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('test_fixes_applied', 0)} failing tests (proven by test results)
4. Refactored {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('functions_refactored', 0)} functions (reduced complexity/length)
5. Added {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('docstrings_added', 0)} docstrings (increased coverage)

**All claims backed by evidence files in LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/**

---

## Artifacts Generated

All evidence is available in:

```
LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/
├── critical/
│   ├── metrics_before.json          # Security/test metrics before fixes
│   ├── metrics_after.json           # Security/test metrics after fixes
│   ├── security_fixes.log           # List of security fixes applied
│   ├── test_fixes.log               # List of test fixes applied
│   ├── files_modified.txt           # Files actually modified
│   └── failures.log                 # Fixes that failed (if any)
├── quality/
│   ├── complexity_before.json       # Code complexity before refactoring
│   ├── complexity_after.json        # Code complexity after refactoring
│   ├── functions_refactored.txt     # Functions actually refactored
│   ├── refactor_log.txt             # Refactoring details
│   └── failures.log                 # Refactorings that failed (if any)
├── docs/
│   ├── coverage_before.json         # Doc coverage before additions
│   ├── coverage_after.json          # Doc coverage after additions
│   ├── docstrings_added.txt         # Docstrings actually added
│   └── failures.log                 # Doc additions that failed (if any)
├── verification/
│   ├── test_results_before.txt      # Test results before fixes
│   ├── test_results_after.txt       # Test results after fixes
│   ├── security_scan_before.txt     # Security scan before fixes
│   └── security_scan_after.txt      # Security scan after fixes
└── report/
    ├── evidence.json                # Compiled evidence metrics
    ├── failures.json                # Documented failures
    ├── commits.txt                  # Git commit history
    ├── files_changed.txt            # Git files changed
    └── fix_report.md                # THIS FILE
```

---

## Notes

**Key Principles Applied:**

1. **Evidence-Based:** Every claim linked to concrete evidence file
2. **Honest Reporting:** Failures documented, not hidden
3. **Actual Changes:** Reports what WAS done, not what could be done
4. **Measurable Impact:** Before/after metrics with percentage changes
5. **Git History:** Real commits with SHAs proving work was done

**Verification Checklist:**

- [ ] All evidence files exist and contain data
- [ ] Before/after metrics show measurable improvement
- [ ] Git history shows commits with fix-related messages
- [ ] Test results prove fixes work
- [ ] Security scans show vulnerability reduction
- [ ] Failures honestly documented with explanations

---

**Report Status:** Evidence-Based
**Generated By:** bx_fix_anal_sub_report v2.0
**Timestamp:** {datetime.now().isoformat()}
"""

# Write report
output_file = Path('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/fix_report.md')
output_file.write_text(report)

print(f"✓ Evidence-based fix report generated: {output_file}")
print()
print(f"Summary:")
print(f"  - Total fixes applied: {total_fixes}")
print(f"  - Successful fixes: {successful_fixes}")
print(f"  - Failed fixes: {failed_fixes}")
print(f"  - Files modified: {evidence.get('actual_changes', {}).get('files_modified', 0)}")
print(f"  - Git commits: {len([c for c in commits if c.strip()])}")
print()

PYTHON_REPORT

echo ""
```

### Step 6: Validate Evidence Quality

```bash
echo "Step 6: Validating evidence quality..."
echo ""

$PYTHON_CMD << 'PYTHON_VALIDATE'
import json
from pathlib import Path

# Load evidence
evidence_file = Path('LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/evidence.json')
if not evidence_file.exists():
    print("✗ CRITICAL: evidence.json not found")
    exit(1)

evidence = json.loads(evidence_file.read_text())

# Check if we have actual changes
actual_changes = evidence.get('actual_changes', {})
total_changes = sum(actual_changes.values()) if actual_changes else 0

if total_changes == 0:
    print("✗ WARNING: No actual changes documented")
    print("  This means NO FIXES were actually applied")
    exit(1)

print(f"✓ Documented {total_changes} actual changes")

# Check if we have before/after metrics
has_security = 'security' in evidence and evidence['security'].get('before') is not None
has_tests = 'tests' in evidence and evidence['tests'].get('before') is not None
has_quality = 'quality' in evidence and bool(evidence.get('quality', {}))
has_docs = 'documentation' in evidence and evidence['documentation'].get('before') is not None

metrics_count = sum([has_security, has_tests, has_quality, has_docs])
print(f"✓ Have before/after metrics for {metrics_count}/4 categories")

if metrics_count == 0:
    print("✗ WARNING: No before/after metrics found")
    print("  Cannot prove improvements without baseline measurements")
    exit(1)

# Check evidence files exist
evidence_files = []
for category in evidence.values():
    if isinstance(category, dict) and 'evidence_files' in category:
        evidence_files.extend(category['evidence_files'])
    elif isinstance(category, dict):
        for subcategory in category.values():
            if isinstance(subcategory, dict) and 'evidence_files' in subcategory:
                evidence_files.extend(subcategory['evidence_files'])

missing_evidence = []
for ev_file in evidence_files:
    if not Path(ev_file).exists():
        missing_evidence.append(ev_file)

if missing_evidence:
    print(f"✗ WARNING: {len(missing_evidence)} evidence files missing:")
    for f in missing_evidence[:5]:
        print(f"    - {f}")
    if len(missing_evidence) > 5:
        print(f"    ...and {len(missing_evidence) - 5} more")
else:
    print(f"✓ All {len(evidence_files)} evidence files present")

print()
print("✓ Evidence quality validation complete")

PYTHON_VALIDATE

echo ""
```

### Step 7: Determine Final Status

```bash
echo "Step 7: Determining final status..."
echo ""

# Load evidence to check if we have actual fixes
EVIDENCE_FILE="LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/evidence.json"
if [ ! -f "$EVIDENCE_FILE" ]; then
    echo "✗ FAILED - No evidence of fixes found"
    echo "FAILED" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt
    exit 1
fi

# Check if we documented any actual changes
TOTAL_CHANGES=$($PYTHON_CMD -c "
import json
from pathlib import Path
evidence = json.loads(Path('$EVIDENCE_FILE').read_text())
actual = evidence.get('actual_changes', {})
print(sum(actual.values()) if actual else 0)
")

if [ "$TOTAL_CHANGES" -eq 0 ]; then
    echo "✗ FAILED - No actual fixes were applied"
    echo "FAILED" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt
    exit 1
fi

# Check for critical failures
FAILURES_FILE="LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/failures.json"
if [ -f "$FAILURES_FILE" ]; then
    FAILURE_COUNT=$($PYTHON_CMD -c "
import json
from pathlib import Path
failures = json.loads(Path('$FAILURES_FILE').read_text())
print(len(failures))
")

    if [ "$FAILURE_COUNT" -gt 0 ]; then
        echo "⚠ PARTIAL SUCCESS - $TOTAL_CHANGES fixes applied, but $FAILURE_COUNT failures documented"
        echo "SUCCESS" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt
        EXIT_CODE=0  # Still successful, just with caveats
    else
        echo "✓ SUCCESS - $TOTAL_CHANGES fixes applied, no failures"
        echo "SUCCESS" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt
        EXIT_CODE=0
    fi
else
    echo "✓ SUCCESS - $TOTAL_CHANGES fixes applied"
    echo "SUCCESS" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt
    EXIT_CODE=0
fi


echo ""
echo "=================================="
echo "FIX REPORT COMPILATION COMPLETE"
echo "=================================="
echo ""
echo "Report: LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/fix_report.md"
echo "Status: $(cat LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt)"
echo "Total Fixes Applied: $TOTAL_CHANGES"
echo "Detailed logs: $LOG_FILE"
echo ""

exit $EXIT_CODE
# Mark as complete
echo "SUCCESS" > LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/status.txt
echo "✓ Report analysis complete"
echo "✓ Status: SUCCESS"
```

## Output Files

All outputs are saved to `LLM-CONTEXT/fix-anal/report/`:

- **status.txt** - Final status: SUCCESS, PARTIAL, or FAILED
- **fix_report.md** - Evidence-based fix report (MAIN OUTPUT)
- **evidence.json** - Compiled evidence metrics with file references
- **failures.json** - Documented failures with explanations
- **commits.txt** - Git commit history
- **files_changed.txt** - List of files actually modified
- **diff_stats.txt** - Git diff statistics

## Integration Protocol

This subagent follows the integration protocol:

1. **Status File**: Creates `status.txt` with "SUCCESS", "PARTIAL", or "FAILED"
2. **Summary File**: Creates `fix_report.md` with evidence-based results
3. **Exit Code**: Returns 0 on success/partial, 1 on failure
4. **Evidence**: All claims backed by concrete evidence files

## Success Criteria

- Evidence files collected from all subagents
- Before/after metrics extracted and compared
- Git commit history documented
- Failures honestly reported
- Evidence-based report generated with proof for all claims
- No unsubstantiated recommendations or future work
- Status reflects actual work completed

## Evidence-Based Reporting

**What This Report Contains:**

- Actual files modified (with names)
- Actual lines changed (with counts)
- Actual commits made (with SHAs)
- Actual metrics improved (with before/after values)
- Actual failures encountered (with explanations)

**What This Report Does NOT Contain:**

- Recommendations for future work
- Suggestions of what could be done
- Analysis without evidence
- Intentions or plans
- Unverified claims

**Key Principle:** If it's in this report, it actually happened and there's evidence to prove it.
