---
phase: 05-file-operation-commands
verified: 2026-01-18T05:00:00Z
status: passed
score: 5/5 must-haves verified
re_verification: false
---

# Phase 5: File Operation Commands Verification Report

**Phase Goal:** File staging and commit commands work correctly
**Verified:** 2026-01-18
**Status:** passed
**Re-verification:** No - initial verification

## Goal Achievement

### Observable Truths

| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|-------|--------|----------|
| 1 | git add <files> stages specified files in Sapling repo | VERIFIED | cmd_add.py calls `run_sl(["add"] + parsed.args)`, tests pass |
| 2 | git add -A stages all changes (new, modified, deleted) | VERIFIED | cmd_add.py detects -A flag and translates to `sl addremove`, test_add_all_with_deleted_file passes |
| 3 | git add --all works the same as -A | VERIFIED | Same code path handles both flags, test_add_all_long_flag passes |
| 4 | git commit -m 'message' creates commit with that message | VERIFIED | cmd_commit.py passes through to `sl commit`, test_commit_with_message_succeeds passes |
| 5 | add -> commit workflow results in clean status | VERIFIED | test_add_commit_workflow passes, shows full workflow works |

**Score:** 5/5 truths verified

### Required Artifacts

| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|----------|----------|--------|---------|
| `cmd_add.py` | Handler for git add command | VERIFIED | 22 lines, exports `handle()`, detects -A/--all for addremove translation |
| `cmd_commit.py` | Handler for git commit command | VERIFIED | 12 lines, exports `handle()`, passthrough to sl commit |
| `gitsl.py` | Dispatch for add and commit | VERIFIED | Lines 18-19: imports, Lines 74-78: dispatch cases |
| `tests/test_cmd_add.py` | E2E tests for add command | VERIFIED | 83 lines, 5 tests covering CMD-02 and CMD-08 |
| `tests/test_cmd_commit.py` | E2E tests for commit command | VERIFIED | 64 lines, 3 tests covering CMD-03 and workflow |

### Artifact Verification Details

#### Level 1: Existence
All 5 artifacts exist at their expected paths.

#### Level 2: Substantive
- `cmd_add.py`: 22 lines (>15 minimum), no stub patterns, has `handle` export
- `cmd_commit.py`: 12 lines (>10 minimum), no stub patterns, has `handle` export  
- `tests/test_cmd_add.py`: 83 lines (>40 minimum), 5 test functions
- `tests/test_cmd_commit.py`: 64 lines (>30 minimum), 3 test functions

#### Level 3: Wired
- `gitsl.py` imports `cmd_add` (line 18) and `cmd_commit` (line 19)
- `gitsl.py` dispatches to `cmd_add.handle(parsed)` (line 75) and `cmd_commit.handle(parsed)` (line 78)
- Both handlers call `run_sl()` from common.py

### Key Link Verification

| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|------|-----|-----|--------|---------|
| gitsl.py | cmd_add.py | import and dispatch | VERIFIED | `import cmd_add` + `cmd_add.handle(parsed)` |
| gitsl.py | cmd_commit.py | import and dispatch | VERIFIED | `import cmd_commit` + `cmd_commit.handle(parsed)` |
| cmd_add.py | common.py | run_sl() call | VERIFIED | `run_sl(["add"] + parsed.args)` and `run_sl(["addremove"] + filtered_args)` |
| cmd_commit.py | common.py | run_sl() call | VERIFIED | `run_sl(["commit"] + parsed.args)` |

### Requirements Coverage

| Requirement | Status | Blocking Issue |
|-------------|--------|----------------|
| CMD-02: git add <files> stages files | SATISFIED | None |
| CMD-03: git commit -m creates commit | SATISFIED | None |
| CMD-08: git add -A stages all changes | SATISFIED | None |

### Anti-Patterns Found

| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|------|------|---------|----------|--------|
| None | - | - | - | No anti-patterns detected |

**Stub pattern check:** No TODO, FIXME, placeholder, or empty return patterns found in cmd_add.py or cmd_commit.py.

### Test Results

```
tests/test_cmd_add.py::TestAddBasic::test_add_new_file_succeeds PASSED
tests/test_cmd_add.py::TestAddBasic::test_add_multiple_files PASSED
tests/test_cmd_add.py::TestAddAll::test_add_all_short_flag PASSED
tests/test_cmd_add.py::TestAddAll::test_add_all_long_flag PASSED
tests/test_cmd_add.py::TestAddAll::test_add_all_with_deleted_file PASSED
tests/test_cmd_commit.py::TestCommitBasic::test_commit_with_message_succeeds PASSED
tests/test_cmd_commit.py::TestCommitBasic::test_commit_nothing_staged_returns_nonzero PASSED
tests/test_cmd_commit.py::TestWorkflow::test_add_commit_workflow PASSED

8 passed in 7.24s
```

### Human Verification Required

None required. All must-haves verified programmatically:
- Code exists and is substantive
- Wiring is complete
- All 8 E2E tests pass
- No stub patterns detected

### Gaps Summary

No gaps found. Phase goal fully achieved.

---

*Verified: 2026-01-18T05:00:00Z*
*Verifier: Claude*
