# REF-2175: Evolve-Run-20260401-220000

**Applies to:** FXA project
**Last updated:** 2026-04-01
**Last reviewed:** 2026-04-01
**Status:** Active

---

## What Is It?

Run log for Evolve-SOP (FXA-2148) execution on 2026-04-01.

---

## Signals

### Document Health

`af validate --json` — 1 issue found:

| Document | Issue |
|----------|-------|
| FXA-2166 | Missing Change History table — document is corrupted (garbled text, incomplete sections) |

### Content Analysis

**FXA-2100 (Leader Mediated Development):**
- HIGH: Role naming collision — "Droid," "GLM," "Coder" used interchangeably without definition
- HIGH: References COR-1601 which does not exist in PKG layer
- MEDIUM: "Final call" authority at 5-round limit is undefined
- MEDIUM: Review Prompt Template is incomplete/fragmentary

**FXA-2102 (Release To PyPI):**
- MEDIUM: FXA-2136 listed as prerequisite but never explicitly invoked in steps
- LOW: Release notes template uses placeholder "NNN" without calculation guidance

**FXA-2125 (Workflow Routing PRJ):**
- MEDIUM: "COR-1602 strict" referenced but "strict" is undefined
- MEDIUM: "New feature" vs "Modify existing" boundary is ambiguous

**FXA-2127 (Commit Alfred Ops):**
- MEDIUM: ALF-0000 deletion is a documented workaround for af index bug
- LOW: No guidance for validation failure cases

**FXA-2136 (Update README):**
- HIGH: All steps are passive checks, not action instructions
- HIGH: "Major feature," "clean project," "key SOPs" are undefined terms
- MEDIUM: No clear handoff to FXA-2127 for commit

**FXA-2166 (Extract Invoke Index Update Helper — CHG):**
- CRITICAL: Document structure destroyed — garbled text, missing all required sections

### GitHub Issues

No git remote configured — skipped.

---

## Candidates

| # | Target | Proposed Change | Evidence |
|---|--------|----------------|----------|
| C1 | FXA-2166 | Fix corrupted CHG — restore Change History table and repair garbled body | `af validate`: "Missing Change History table" |
| C2 | FXA-2100 | Standardize role naming — replace mixed Droid/GLM/Coder with consistent terms + alias table | Content analysis: 3 terms for same role |
| C3 | FXA-2100 | Remove dangling COR-1601 reference | Content analysis: COR-1601 not in PKG |
| C4 | FXA-2136 | Rewrite passive check steps as action instructions | Content analysis: non-deterministic steps |

**Note:** C3 invalidated during evaluation — COR-1601 exists in PKG layer (`af read COR-1601` succeeds). The content analysis incorrectly reported it missing.

| C5 | FXA-2100 | Add af command instructions to Review Prompt Template for alfred_ops dispatches | Live failure: Gemini agent couldn't find FXA-2165 during PRP review |

---

## Evaluation

Weights: Necessity 30% / Consistency 25% / Atomicity 20% / Actionability 15% / Impact 10%

| # | Nec (30%) | Con (25%) | Ato (20%) | Act (15%) | Imp (10%) | **Score** | **Result** |
|---|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|------------|
| C1 | 10 | 10 | 10 | 9 | 7 | **9.65** | PASS |
| C2 | 8 | 9 | 7 | 8 | 9 | **8.25** | PASS |
| C3 | — | — | — | — | — | **N/A** | INVALID (COR-1601 exists) |
| C4 | 7 | 8 | 4 | 6 | 5 | **6.55** | DISCARD |

C3 invalidated: COR-1601 exists in PKG layer.
C4 discarded: full SOP rewrite violates atomicity (scope too large for evolve run).

| C5 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | **9.0** | PASS |

**Passing candidates: C1, C2, C5**

---

## Implementation

| CHG | PRP | Target | Change | Status |
|-----|-----|--------|--------|--------|
| FXA-2179 | FXA-2176 | FXA-2166 | Reconstructed corrupted CHG document | Completed |
| FXA-2180 | FXA-2177 | FXA-2100 | Replaced "Droid" with "GLM" (3 locations) | Completed |
| FXA-2181 | FXA-2178 | FXA-2100 | Added optional Tool Context to Review Prompt Template | Completed |

Hard gate: `af validate` — 0 issues (passed).
CHG review: passed (Codex 9.4–9.6, Gemini 10.0 all three).

---

## Change History

| Date | Change | By |
|------|--------|----|
| 2026-04-01 | Initial version | — |
