# REF-2172: Evolve-SOP-Run-20260401-154338

**Applies to:** FXA project
**Last updated:** 2026-04-01
**Last reviewed:** 2026-04-01
**Status:** Active

---

## What Is It?

Run log for Evolve-SOP (SOP-2148) execution on 2026-04-01.

---

## Signals

### Document Health (af validate)
- 1 issue: FXA-2166 missing Change History table (corrupted CHG document)

### GitHub Issues
- No issues with `agent-input` label

### Content Analysis (18 findings across 8 documents)

**Critical (1):** FXA-2166 corrupted CHG — body malformed, missing sections
**High (3):** FXA-2100 scoring mismatch with COR-1610; FXA-2148/2149 "review gate" undefined
**Medium (10):** Various actionability issues, undefined terms, missing steps
**Low (4):** Hardcoded paths, formatting inconsistencies

---

## Candidates

| # | Target | Change | Evidence |
|---|--------|--------|----------|
| S1 | FXA-2148 + FXA-2149 | Define "review gate" = "both reviewers score >= 9.0 per COR-1602" | Content analysis: term used but never defined in either SOP |
| S2 | FXA-2100 | Align scoring dimensions with COR-1610 (5 dims not 4) | Content analysis: FXA-2100 defines 4 dims, COR-1610 defines 5 |
| S3 | FXA-2148 + FXA-2149 | Define "Generator role" and "Evaluator role" explicitly | Content analysis: roles referenced but never defined |
| S4 | FXA-2166 | Fix corrupted CHG — add proper body structure and Change History | af validate: missing Change History table |
| S5 | FXA-2127 | Replace hardcoded absolute path with `--root` option | Content analysis: hardcoded /Users/frank path |
| S6 | FXA-2102 | Add explicit CHANGELOG update step to release SOP | Content analysis: CHANGELOG in example but not in Steps |

---

## Evaluation

Weights: Necessity 30% / Consistency 25% / Atomicity 20% / Actionability 15% / Impact 10%

| # | N (30%) | Con (25%) | Ato (20%) | Act (15%) | Imp (10%) | Score | Pass? |
|---|---------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-----------|-------|-------|
| S1 | 9 | 9 | 8 | 10 | 9 | **9.05** | YES |
| S2 | 8 | 10 | 9 | 8 | 7 | **8.65** | YES |
| S3 | 7 | 8 | 7 | 9 | 6 | **7.45** | YES |
| S4 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 6 | 5 | **8.05** | YES |
| S5 | 6 | 7 | 9 | 8 | 4 | **6.85** | NO |
| S6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 7 | 6 | **7.50** | YES |

**Discarded:** S5 (6.85 < 7.0)
**Passing:** S1 (9.05), S2 (8.65), S3 (7.45), S4 (8.05), S6 (7.50)

---

## Implementation

### S1 + S2: Define review gate + align scoring — IMPLEMENTED

- **Issue:** frankyxhl/alfred#13
- **PRP:** FXA-2173 (Codex 9.5, Gemini 9.3)
- **CHG:** FXA-2174 (Codex 9.5, Gemini 10.0)
- **Hard gate:** af validate passes (only pre-existing FXA-2166 failure)
- **Commit:** alfred_ops `506da72`

### S3, S4, S6 — DEFERRED to next evolve-sop run

- S3 (7.45): Define "Generator role" and "Evaluator role" in FXA-2148/2149
- S4 (8.05): Fix corrupted FXA-2166 CHG document
- S6 (7.50): Add CHANGELOG update step to FXA-2102 release SOP

---

## Change History

| Date | Change | By |
|------|--------|----|
| 2026-04-01 | Initial version | — |
