# REF-2187: Evolve-Run-20260404-001357

**Applies to:** FXA project
**Last updated:** 2026-04-04
**Last reviewed:** 2026-04-04
**Status:** Active

---

## What Is It?

Evolve-SOP run log for 2026-04-04. Tracks signals, candidates, scores, and outcomes.

---

## Signals

### S1: Validation failure — FXA-2185 invalid status
- `af validate` reports: FXA-2185 has Status "Implemented" which is not valid for CHG type
- COR-0002 allows CHG statuses: Proposed, Approved, In Progress, Completed, Rolled Back
- Fix: change "Implemented" to "Completed"

### S2: FXA-2125 references deprecated FXA-2127
- FXA-2125 decision tree item 9 ("End of session?") routes to FXA-2127 (Commit Alfred Ops)
- FXA-2127 was deprecated per FXA-2186 (alfred_ops merged into fx_alfred)
- FXA-2186 step 10 explicitly called for this cleanup but it was not completed for FXA-2125

### S3: FXA-2125 golden rule contains stale "no remote" claim
- Golden rule says: "fx_alfred: Documents live in rules/ (PRJ layer), document changes, no remote (local git only)"
- fx_alfred has remote: git@github.com:frankyxhl/alfred.git
- The "no remote (local git only)" was inherited from the old alfred_ops repo (which was local-only)

### S4: No GitHub issues with `agent-input` label
### S5: Session logs — skipped (not available)

## Candidates

### C1: Fix FXA-2125 stale references from alfred_ops merge
- **Target:** FXA-2125 (Workflow Routing PRJ)
- **Changes:** (a) Remove decision tree item 9 reference to deprecated FXA-2127; (b) Remove "no remote (local git only)" from golden rules
- **Evidence:** S2, S3

### C2: Fix FXA-2185 invalid CHG status
- **Target:** FXA-2185
- **Change:** Status "Implemented" → "Completed"
- **Evidence:** S1

## Evaluation (Evaluator role — skeptical by default)

### C1 Score: 8.7

| Dimension | Weight | Score | Reasoning |
|-----------|--------|-------|-----------|
| Necessity | 30% | 9 | FXA-2186 step 10 explicitly required this cleanup; routing doc sends users to deprecated SOP |
| Consistency | 25% | 9 | FXA-2127 marked Deprecated yet routing doc treats it as active; "no remote" conflicts with actual git config |
| Atomicity | 20% | 8 | Two changes but same root cause (alfred_ops merge cleanup incomplete) |
| Actionability | 15% | 9 | Clear what to change in decision tree and golden rules |
| Impact | 10% | 8 | Routing doc consulted at every session start |
| **Weighted** | | **8.7** | **PASS (>= 7.0)** |

### C2 Score: 8.6

| Dimension | Weight | Score | Reasoning |
|-----------|--------|-------|-----------|
| Necessity | 30% | 8 | Validation failure is concrete evidence |
| Consistency | 25% | 9 | Directly violates COR-0002 allowed status values |
| Atomicity | 20% | 10 | Single field change |
| Actionability | 15% | 10 | Trivially executable |
| Impact | 10% | 4 | One document, not frequently referenced |
| **Weighted** | | **8.6** | **PASS (>= 7.0)** |

## Outcome

Both candidates pass threshold (>= 7.0). Proceeding to Phase 5.

## Implementation

### C1: FXA-2125 stale refs
- **PRP:** FXA-2188 — Approved (Codex R1: 9.9, DeepSeek R2: 9.9, Gemini R2: 10.0)
- **CHG:** FXA-2190 — Completed (Gemini: 9.8, DeepSeek: 9.4)
- **Changes:** Removed decision tree item 9, updated golden rule in FXA-2125

### C2: FXA-2185 status fix
- **PRP:** FXA-2189 — Approved (DeepSeek: 9.7, Gemini: 9.6)
- **CHG:** FXA-2191 — Completed (Gemini: 9.6, DeepSeek: 9.4)
- **Changes:** FXA-2185 Status "Implemented" → "Completed"

### Notes
- Codex was rate-limited during this run; DeepSeek substituted as second reviewer
- GitHub issue: #16
- Branch: chore/16-evolve-sop-20260404

---

## Change History

| Date | Change | By |
|------|--------|----|
| 2026-04-04 | Initial version | — |
