# Project Review — xwschema (REF_35_REVIEW)

**Company:** eXonware.com  
**Last Updated:** 07-Feb-2026  
**Producing guide:** GUIDE_35_REVIEW.md

---

## Purpose

Project-level review summary and current status for xwschema (schema formats and validation). Updated after full review per GUIDE_35_REVIEW. Downstream REFs refreshed from REF_01_REQ.

---

## Maturity Estimate

| Dimension | Level | Notes |
|-----------|--------|------|
| **Overall** | **Alpha (Medium)** | JSON Schema, OpenAPI, GraphQL, Protobuf, Avro, WSDL, XSD, Swagger; registry, validation, conversion |
| Code | Medium–High | engine, formats, registry, operations; facade, builder; xwdata as engine base |
| Tests | High | 0.core, 1.unit, 2.integration, 3.advance |
| Docs | Medium–High | REF_01_REQ, REF_11_COMP, REF_12_IDEA, REF_13_ARCH, REF_14_DX, REF_15_API, REF_21_PLAN, REF_22_PROJECT, REF_35_REVIEW, REF_51_TEST, REF_54_BENCH; logs/reviews/ |
| IDEA/Requirements | **Clear** | REF_01_REQ complete (14/14); REF_11, REF_12, REF_13, REF_14, REF_15, REF_21, REF_22 present and sourced from REF_01_REQ |

---

## Critical Issues

- **None blocking.**

---

## IDEA / Requirements Clarity

- **Clear.** REF_01_REQ is the single source (14/14 clarity). REF_11_COMP, REF_12_IDEA, REF_13_ARCH, REF_14_DX, REF_15_API, REF_21_PLAN, REF_22_PROJECT are present and sourced from REF_01_REQ. xwdata is the base of the engine—use it; anti-goal is reimplementing or bypassing xwdata.

---

## Missing vs Guides

- REF_01_REQ.md — present, complete.
- REF_11_COMP.md — present; compliance stance from REF_01_REQ sec. 4.
- REF_12_IDEA.md, REF_14_DX.md, REF_21_PLAN.md — present; filled from REF_01_REQ (07-Feb-2026).
- REF_22_PROJECT.md, REF_13_ARCH.md, REF_15_API.md — present; populated from REF_01_REQ.
- REF_54_BENCH.md — present; benchmarks/performance (example + 3.advance tests) per gap review.
- REF_35_REVIEW.md (this file).
- docs/logs/reviews/ and REVIEW_*.md — present (e.g. [REVIEW_20260207_120000_000_REQUIREMENTS.md](logs/reviews/REVIEW_20260207_120000_000_REQUIREMENTS.md), [REVIEW_20260207_170000_000_DOCS_CODE_TESTS_EXAMPLES_BENCH_GAP.md](logs/reviews/REVIEW_20260207_170000_000_DOCS_CODE_TESTS_EXAMPLES_BENCH_GAP.md)).

---

## Next Steps

1. ~~Add docs/REF_22_PROJECT.md (vision, format list, milestones).~~ Done.
2. ~~Add REF_13_ARCH.~~ Done.
3. ~~Add REVIEW_*.md in docs/logs/reviews/.~~ Present.
4. ~~Populate REF_22, REF_13, REF_15 from REF_01_REQ.~~ Done.
5. Confirm all test layers pass and document v1 DoD (REF_51_TEST or REF_22).
6. ~~Add REF_12_IDEA, REF_14_DX, REF_21_PLAN.~~ Done (07-Feb-2026).

---

*Requirements source: [REF_01_REQ.md](REF_01_REQ.md). Requirements alignment: [logs/reviews/REVIEW_20260207_120000_000_REQUIREMENTS.md](logs/reviews/REVIEW_20260207_120000_000_REQUIREMENTS.md). Doc/code/tests/examples/bench gap: [logs/reviews/REVIEW_20260207_170000_000_DOCS_CODE_TESTS_EXAMPLES_BENCH_GAP.md](logs/reviews/REVIEW_20260207_170000_000_DOCS_CODE_TESTS_EXAMPLES_BENCH_GAP.md). Ecosystem: [REVIEW_20260207_ECOSYSTEM_STATUS_SUMMARY.md](../../../docs/logs/reviews/REVIEW_20260207_ECOSYSTEM_STATUS_SUMMARY.md) (repo root).*
