# Review by Linus Torvalds (Round 1)

---

Here's my review as Linus Torvalds:

## Review Summary

**VERDICT: approve**

### What I looked at:
- The PRD's 7 functional requirements against the actual implementation
- `agent.py` changes (4 lines — `resume` parameter threading)
- `cli.py` changes (session state wiring in both REPL and TUI closures)
- 181 tests passing (168 CLI + 13 agent)
- No TODOs, no secrets, no placeholder code

### Key findings:

1. **`agent.py`** — Clean, minimal. The conditional kwargs unpacking (`**({...} if resume else {})`) avoids polluting SDK options when resume isn't needed. This is the right pattern.

2. **`_run_direct_agent()`** — Return type change from `bool` to `tuple[bool, str | None]` is correct. The graceful fallback (retry without resume on failure, lines 207-219) is exactly right — fail once, try clean, don't loop forever.

3. **Session state management** — `last_direct_session_id` is cleared in all the right places: mode transitions, pipeline entry, `/new` command, and on failure. No state leaks across mode boundaries.

4. **One nit** — The TUI callback detects `/new` via string matching (`"Conversation cleared" in command_output`) rather than a structured signal. Fragile but functional. Not a blocker.

5. **Tests** — Good lifecycle coverage: store on success, clear on mode switch, clear on `/new`, pass resume through, fallback retry tested.

### Bottom line:
The PRD said "3 lines of real logic" and that's roughly what the core change is. Store a session ID, pass it back, clear it on transitions. Uses the SDK's native resume rather than reinventing transcript replay. The data structures are simple, the control flow is obvious, the fallback is correct. Ship it.

VERDICT: approve

FINDINGS:
- [src/colonyos/agent.py]: Clean 4-line change, correct conditional kwargs unpacking
- [src/colonyos/cli.py]: Session state properly cleared on all mode transitions and failures
- [src/colonyos/cli.py]: String-matching "Conversation cleared" for /new detection is fragile but functional
- [tests/test_cli.py]: 168 tests covering full session lifecycle — all passing
- [tests/test_agent.py]: Both positive and negative resume option cases covered

SYNTHESIS:
Straightforward, well-executed feature. The implementation uses the SDK's native resume mechanism, the data structures are simple (one `str | None` per closure), the control flow is obvious, and the fallback behavior is correct. The branch carries unrelated prior TUI/routing diff, but the session persistence changes themselves are minimal and correctly scoped. Ship it.
