# Review by Linus Torvalds (Round 1)

Now I have a clear picture. Let me write the review.

---

Right. Let me be blunt, because that's what you need to hear.

**This branch has zero implementation.** The branch `HEAD` and `main` point to the exact same commit (`55b4048`). Not a single line of code was written for this PRD. What's sitting in the working tree is an unresolved merge conflict from other branches — not implementation work.

Let me enumerate what I see:

1. **No new files created**: `ceo_profiles.py`, `log_writer.py` — the two core new modules the task file calls for — don't exist.
2. **No commits**: `git diff main...HEAD` is empty. Zero. Nothing.
3. **Merge conflicts everywhere**: `pyproject.toml`, `app.py`, `styles.py`, `transcript.py`, `memory.py`, `conftest.py` — all in "Unmerged" state. Someone tried a merge/rebase and walked away without resolving it.
4. **All 8 parent tasks unchecked**: Every single task in the task file is `- [ ]`. Not one subtask completed.
5. **The only committed staged file** is `tests/test_instructions.py` (270 lines) which appears to be from the *superpowers* PRD, not this one.

The unstaged diff in `transcript.py` (+172/-43 lines) and `test_transcript.py` (+134 lines) *might* be partial work toward Task 1.0 (auto-scroll fix), but it's uncommitted, sitting on top of merge conflicts, and I can't even evaluate it properly because the working tree is in a broken state.

---

VERDICT: request-changes

FINDINGS:
- [branch]: Branch HEAD is identical to main — zero implementation commits exist
- [working tree]: 8 files in unresolved merge conflict state (UU/AA status) — working tree is broken
- [src/colonyos/ceo_profiles.py]: Required new file (Task 2.0, FR-2) does not exist
- [src/colonyos/tui/log_writer.py]: Required new file (Task 3.0, FR-3) does not exist
- [src/colonyos/tui/widgets/transcript.py]: Possible partial auto-scroll work exists as uncommitted unstaged changes, but cannot be evaluated due to merge conflicts
- [src/colonyos/cli.py]: No changes for auto-in-TUI wiring (Task 5.0, FR-1) — the core feature
- [src/colonyos/tui/adapter.py]: No new message types (IterationHeaderMsg, LoopCompleteMsg) added
- [src/colonyos/tui/widgets/status_bar.py]: No iteration count display added
- [src/colonyos/tui/widgets/hint_bar.py]: No Ctrl+S hint or auto command hint added
- [cOS_tasks/]: All 8 parent tasks and all subtasks remain unchecked

SYNTHESIS:
There is nothing to review. This branch is a planning artifact — it has a PRD, a task file, and a branch name, but not a single committed line of implementation. The working tree is in a broken merge-conflict state that would need to be resolved before any work can even begin. Every functional requirement (FR-1 through FR-5) is completely unimplemented. The branch needs to be reset to a clean state, the merge conflicts resolved, and the actual implementation work needs to happen before this can be reviewed. Ship code, not plans.
