# Review by Linus Torvalds (Round 1)

Here's my review as Linus Torvalds:

---

**VERDICT: request-changes**

### The Good
The core router module is well-designed — simple data structures, correct fail-open behavior, clean prompt construction, proper input sanitization, and a readable CLI guard clause. 82 tests pass. The two-stage architecture (zero-tool classification → read-only Q&A) is the right design.

### The Ship-Blocking Bug
**`_log_router_decision` is imported in `cli.py:613` but doesn't exist in `router.py`.** This will crash with `ImportError` the moment *any user* runs `colonyos run` with routing enabled. The entire feature is broken at runtime.

### Key Missing Pieces
1. **`_log_router_decision()` not implemented** — FR-8 audit logging missing entirely, and causes the crash above
2. **REPL has no routing** — `_run_repl()` still calls `run_orchestrator()` directly (FR-4 incomplete)
3. **Slack not refactored** — `triage_message()` in `slack.py` is unchanged (FR-2 not done)
4. **All tasks still marked `[ ]`** — despite tasks 1-6 being substantially complete

### Minor Issues
- Private function (`_log_router_decision`) imported across module boundaries — should be public if it's part of the API
- Repeated `config.project.name if config.project else ""` extraction pattern — should be extracted once

The review is saved at `cOS_reviews/reviews/linus_torvalds/20260321_160000_round2_right_now_the_pipeline_always_runs_this_huge_planner_implementation_orchestratio.md`.
