# Review by Principal Systems Engineer (Google/Stripe caliber) (Round 3)

---

## Review — Principal Systems Engineer (Google/Stripe caliber)

**VERDICT: approve**

### Assessment

After round 2 fixes, this is a solid V1 daemon: 818 lines of orchestration, 183 lines of atomic state management, 71 passing tests. All previous P0 blockers are resolved — `WatchdogSec` removed, `run_pipeline_for_queue_item()` bridges items to the pipeline, Slack kill switch works with user auth, budget alerts fire at 80%/100%.

### Key Findings

| Sev | Finding |
|-----|---------|
| **P1** | **Daily digest (FR-10) not implemented** — `digest_hour_utc` config exists but there's no scheduling or posting logic. Operators get heartbeat every 4h but no end-of-day summary. |
| **P1** | **`_pipeline_running` and `_pending_count()` read without lock** in `_tick()` — inconsistent with the stated lock discipline. Benign under CPython GIL but architecturally wrong. |
| **P1** | **Self-modification guard not implemented** — PRD says `src/colonyos/` should be flagged off-limits in CEO prompt. Not enforced. |
| **P2** | **Starvation promotion cascades** — once an item crosses the 24h mark, it gets promoted every 5-second tick (P3→P2→P1→P0 in ~15 seconds). Should track last promotion time. |
| **P2** | **Slack listener thread dies silently on disconnect** — no retry/reconnection logic, no health surface for dead thread. |
| **P2** | **Cleanup scheduling lists merged branches but never prunes them** — dead work. |
| **P3** | PID file write ordering (truncate after write), fragile `save_config` diff check, no operational counters. |

### Why Approve

None of these are ship-blockers. The daemon will:
- Start, acquire PID lock, recover from crashes ✅
- Poll GitHub issues with label filtering and dedup ✅
- Execute items in priority order through the full pipeline ✅
- Enforce daily budget with threshold alerts ✅
- Trip circuit breaker on consecutive failures ✅
- Respond to Slack kill-switch commands ✅
- Persist state atomically across crashes ✅
- Report health via `/healthz` with live daemon state ✅

**Recommendation**: Fix the starvation cascade (finding #4) before the first production week — it will cause surprising priority inversions once real items age past 24h. The daily digest and Slack reconnection should follow shortly after.

Review written to `cOS_reviews/reviews/principal_systems_engineer_google_stripe_caliber/20260329_210000_round3_...md`.
