# Review by Staff Security Engineer (Round 4)

I now have a complete picture. Here is my review:

---

## Security Review — Staff Security Engineer

### Checklist Assessment

#### Completeness
- [x] All functional requirements from the PRD are implemented (FR-1 through FR-21 covered)
- [x] QueueItem has `source_type="slack"`, `slack_ts`, `slack_channel`, `base_branch`
- [x] Triage agent uses haiku model, no tool access, structured JSON output
- [x] Watch→Queue unification with executor thread
- [x] Daily budget, circuit breaker, max queue depth all implemented
- [x] No TODO/placeholder code remains (one dead assignment noted below)

#### Quality
- [x] Tests are comprehensive — 389 new lines in `test_slack.py`, plus tests in config/models/orchestrator/queue
- [x] Code follows existing project conventions (dataclass patterns, `to_dict`/`from_dict`, threading model)
- [x] No unnecessary dependencies added
- [x] Backward compatibility maintained for deserialization

#### Safety — Detailed Findings

**POSITIVE — Triage Agent Sandboxing (FR-4):**
The triage agent is correctly invoked with `allowed_tools=[]`, meaning it has zero tool access. This is the single most important security control for this feature. The LLM only receives sanitized text and returns JSON. Cost is capped at `$0.05` per call.

**POSITIVE — Branch Name Injection Defense (Defense-in-Depth):**
`is_valid_git_ref()` uses a strict character allowlist (`[a-zA-Z0-9._/-]`), rejects `..` traversal, leading/trailing slashes, and names >255 chars. Validation happens at *three* layers: (1) `extract_base_branch()`, (2) `_parse_triage_response()`, and (3) `orchestrator.run()`. The subprocess calls use list form (`["git", "checkout", base_branch]`), not `shell=True`, preventing command injection even if validation were bypassed. Tests explicitly cover `main; rm -rf /`, backtick injection, `../etc/passwd`, and newlines.

**POSITIVE — No Dangerous Budget Defaults:**
`daily_budget_usd` defaults to `None` (disabled), requiring explicit opt-in. Negative/zero values are rejected at config parse time. This prevents accidental unbounded spend in always-on mode.

**POSITIVE — Content Sanitization Reuse:**
The triage prompt uses `sanitize_slack_content()` which delegates to the existing `sanitize_untrusted_content()` function (XML tag stripping). The same boundary used by the existing `format_slack_as_prompt()` is preserved.

**CONCERN — `bypassPermissions` on Triage Agent:**
While `allowed_tools=[]` correctly gives zero tool access, the triage agent still runs with `permission_mode="bypassPermissions"` (hardcoded in `run_phase`). This is harmless in practice since there are no tools to bypass, but it violates strict least-privilege principle. If a future change to the agent SDK introduced implicit tools (e.g., a built-in web fetch), the bypass would silently grant access.

**CONCERN — No Persistent Audit Log for Triage Decisions:**
Triage accept/skip decisions are logged via `logger.info()` but not persisted to a queryable artifact. For an always-on agent making autonomous decisions about what to work on, there is no way to audit "what did the bot skip and why?" after the fact. The `SlackWatchState` tracks costs and failures but not the triage verdicts themselves. This is important for detecting prompt injection attempts that might cause the triage agent to consistently skip legitimate bugs or accept crafted messages.

**MINOR — Dead Assignment in Circuit Breaker:**
In `QueueExecutor._is_paused()`, line `cooldown_sec = self._watch_state.consecutive_failures` is immediately overwritten by `cooldown_sec = config.slack.circuit_breaker_cooldown_minutes * 60`. This is a code smell (looks like leftover debugging), not a security issue.

**MINOR — Thread Safety of `_slack_client`:**
The `_slack_client` nonlocal is written without `state_lock`, but the `_slack_client_ready` Event provides sufficient happens-before ordering for the executor thread. The event handler's idempotent check (`if not _slack_client_ready.is_set()`) has a theoretical race where two events could both pass the check, but both would write the same valid client reference, so this is benign.

---

VERDICT: approve

FINDINGS:
- [src/colonyos/agent.py]: `permission_mode="bypassPermissions"` is hardcoded for all phases including triage — triage is protected by `allowed_tools=[]` but a future SDK change adding implicit tools could silently expand access
- [src/colonyos/slack.py]: No persistent audit trail for triage accept/skip decisions — only transient logger output; an attacker who crafts messages to manipulate triage has no durable evidence trail
- [src/colonyos/cli.py]: Dead assignment `cooldown_sec = self._watch_state.consecutive_failures` in `_is_paused()` is immediately overwritten — cosmetic issue suggesting incomplete cleanup
- [src/colonyos/slack.py]: `is_valid_git_ref()` + defense-in-depth validation at 3 layers is exemplary security practice for user-supplied branch names passed to subprocess
- [src/colonyos/slack.py]: Triage agent correctly uses `allowed_tools=[]` with `$0.05` budget cap — minimal blast radius for prompt injection via Slack messages

SYNTHESIS:
From a supply chain and least-privilege perspective, this implementation is solid. The highest-risk surface — an LLM evaluating untrusted Slack messages — is properly sandboxed with zero tool access, a micro-budget, and content sanitization. Branch name handling demonstrates exemplary defense-in-depth with allowlist validation at extraction, parsing, and point-of-use, combined with subprocess list-form invocation. Budget controls have no dangerous defaults and include both per-run and daily caps with circuit breaker protection. The two concerns I flag are (1) the absence of a persistent triage audit log, which matters for detecting manipulation patterns over time in an always-on system, and (2) the `bypassPermissions` mode being applied even to the zero-tool triage agent — a latent risk if the underlying SDK evolves. Neither is blocking, but both should be tracked for near-term follow-up. The implementation correctly maintains all existing safety controls (dedup, rate limiting, approval gates) while adding the new triage and queue layers.