# Review by Linus Torvalds (Round 1)

Here's my review as Linus Torvalds:

---

**VERDICT: request-changes**

The data structures are solid — `QueueItem`, `QueueState`, status enums, atomic persistence — all correct and well-tested (41 tests, 906 total pass). The core execution loop handles the happy path well: sequential processing, budget/time caps, failure isolation, NO-GO detection, and issue re-fetching at execution time. All PRD requirements (FR-1 through FR-18) have implementations.

**But there are real problems:**

1. **SIGINT/resume bug (correctness)**: Items are marked RUNNING before `run_orchestrator()` is called. If the user hits Ctrl+C, that item stays RUNNING forever and gets skipped on resume — violating FR-14's durability guarantee. This needs a signal handler or a RUNNING→PENDING reset at `queue start` time.

2. **`import uuid as _uuid` inside loop bodies**: Stdlib import re-executed every iteration, with a pointless underscore alias. Move it to module scope.

3. **`_print_queue_summary()` creates its own `Console()`** instead of accepting one as a parameter — breaks the pattern used by every other Rich renderer in the codebase.

4. **Duration formatting duplicated** instead of reusing `_format_duration()` from `ui.py`.

5. **cli.py is 2062 lines** — queue persistence and rendering helpers should be extracted to a `queue.py` module.

6. **Branch contains ~6000 lines of unrelated features** (ci-fix, show command, etc.) — should be separate branches.

The review has been written to `cOS_reviews/reviews/linus_torvalds/round_1_queue.md`.