# AGOR Coordination Audit - Implementation vs Documentation

## 🔍 Comprehensive Analysis

This audit checks every hotkey, template, and coordination feature to ensure everything harmonizes and there are no contradictions or missing implementations.

## 📊 Hotkey Implementation Status

### ✅ **FULLY IMPLEMENTED**

| Hotkey      | Function            | Implementation        | Status     |
| ----------- | ------------------- | --------------------- | ---------- |
| `a`         | Analyze codebase    | code_exploration.py   | ✅ Working |
| `f`         | Show full files     | code_exploration.py   | ✅ Working |
| `co`        | Changes only        | code_exploration.py   | ✅ Working |
| `tree`      | Directory structure | code_exploration.py   | ✅ Working |
| `grep`      | Search files        | code_exploration.py   | ✅ Working |
| `snapshot`  | Create snapshot     | snapshot_templates.py | ✅ Working |
| `receive`   | Receive snapshot    | snapshot_templates.py | ✅ Working |
| `snapshots` | List snapshots      | snapshot_templates.py | ✅ Working |
| `meta`      | AGOR feedback       | agor-meta.md          | ✅ Working |
| `init`      | Initialize role     | README_ai.md          | ✅ Working |
| `status`    | Check status        | README_ai.md          | ✅ Working |
| `sync`      | Pull changes        | README_ai.md          | ✅ Working |

### 🟡 **PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED** (Templates exist, execution protocols missing)

| Hotkey | Function            | Template                         | Execution Protocol | Gap                     |
| ------ | ------------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------ | ----------------------- |
| `sp`   | Strategic planning  | ❌ Missing                       | ❌ Missing         | No template or protocol |
| `bp`   | Break down project  | ✅ project_planning_templates.py | ❌ Missing         | Need execution protocol |
| `ar`   | Architecture review | ❌ Missing                       | ❌ Missing         | No template or protocol |
| `ct`   | Create team         | ✅ project_planning_templates.py | ❌ Missing         | Need execution protocol |
| `tm`   | Team management     | ❌ Missing                       | ❌ Missing         | No template or protocol |
| `hp`   | Snapshot prompts    | ✅ agent_prompt_templates.py     | ❌ Missing         | Need execution protocol |
| `wf`   | Workflow design     | ✅ project_planning_templates.py | ❌ Missing         | Need execution protocol |
| `qg`   | Quality gates       | ❌ Missing                       | ❌ Missing         | No template or protocol |
| `eo`   | Error optimization  | ❌ Missing                       | ❌ Missing         | No template or protocol |

### ❌ **NOT IMPLEMENTED** (Documentation exists, no implementation)

| Hotkey | Function           | Documentation                | Implementation           | Gap                                    |
| ------ | ------------------ | ---------------------------- | ------------------------ | -------------------------------------- |
| `ss`   | Strategy selection | ✅ strategies.md             | ❌ Missing               | Need strategy_protocols.py integration |
| `pd`   | Parallel Divergent | ✅ strategies.md + templates | ✅ strategy_protocols.py | **FIXED**                              |
| `pl`   | Pipeline           | ✅ strategies.md + templates | ✅ strategy_protocols.py | **FIXED**                              |
| `sw`   | Swarm              | ✅ strategies.md + templates | ✅ strategy_protocols.py | **FIXED**                              |
| `rt`   | Red Team           | ✅ strategies.md + templates | ❌ Missing               | Need execution protocol                |
| `mb`   | Mob Programming    | ✅ strategies.md + templates | ❌ Missing               | Need execution protocol                |

### 🔧 **Memory Commands**

| Hotkey       | Function          | Implementation   | Status     |
| ------------ | ----------------- | ---------------- | ---------- |
| `mem-add`    | Add memory        | memory_sync.py   | ✅ Working |
| `mem-search` | Search memory     | memory_sync.py   | ✅ Working |

## 🔍 **Documentation Conflicts & Duplicates**

### **Duplicate Strategy Documentation**

1. **strategies.md** - High-level strategy overview
2. **project_planning_templates.py** - Strategy templates
3. **agent_prompt_templates.py** - Strategy prompts
4. **README_ai.md** - Strategy hotkeys

**Resolution**: These complement each other, no conflicts found.

### **Snapshot Documentation Overlap**

1. **snapshots.md** - Snapshot procedures
2. **snapshot_templates.py** - Snapshot implementation
3. **agent_prompt_templates.py** - Snapshot prompts

**Resolution**: These work together, no conflicts found.

### **Bundle Mode Instructions Duplication**

1. **BUNDLE_INSTRUCTIONS.md** - Basic bundle instructions
2. **bundle-mode.md** - Comprehensive bundle guide
3. **quick-start.md** - Quick bundle setup
4. **google-ai-studio.md** - Platform-specific instructions

**Resolution**: Different levels of detail for different use cases. No conflicts.

## ❌ **Missing Implementations**

### **1. Strategic Planning (`sp`)**

**Gap**: No template or execution protocol
**Need**:

- Template in project_planning_templates.py
- Execution protocol in strategy_protocols.py
- Integration with agent_coordination.py

### **2. Architecture Review (`ar`)**

**Gap**: No template or execution protocol
**Need**:

- Template for architecture analysis
- Review checklist and criteria
- Integration with snapshot system

### **3. Team Management (`tm`)**

**Gap**: No ongoing team coordination protocol
**Need**:

- Team status tracking
- Agent assignment management
- Progress monitoring

### **4. Quality Gates (`qg`)**

**Gap**: No quality validation framework
**Need**:

- Quality criteria templates
- Validation protocols
- Integration with snapshot system

### **5. Error Optimization (`eo`)**

**Gap**: No error analysis framework
**Need**:

- Error pattern analysis
- Optimization recommendations
- Performance improvement protocols

### **6. Red Team & Mob Programming Execution**

**Gap**: Templates exist but no execution protocols
**Need**:

- Execution protocols in strategy_protocols.py
- Integration with agent_coordination.py

## 🎯 **Harmonization Issues**

### **1. Strategy Selection Disconnect**

- **Issue**: `ss` hotkey documented but not connected to strategy_protocols.py
- **Fix**: Create strategy selection function that uses existing templates

### **2. Snapshot Prompt Integration**

- **Issue**: `hp` hotkey exists but not integrated with snapshot_templates.py
- **Fix**: Connect hp to generate_snapshot_prompt functions

### **3. Workflow Design Execution**

- **Issue**: `wf` hotkey and templates exist but no execution protocol
- **Fix**: Create workflow execution protocol

## 📋 **Priority Fixes Needed**

### **High Priority** (Breaks documented functionality)

1. **Strategy Selection (`ss`)** - Connect to strategy_protocols.py
2. **Red Team (`rt`)** - Add execution protocol
3. **Mob Programming (`mb`)** - Add execution protocol

### **Medium Priority** (Improves usability)

4. **Strategic Planning (`sp`)** - Add template and protocol
5. **Architecture Review (`ar`)** - Add template and protocol
6. **Team Management (`tm`)** - Add ongoing coordination

### **Low Priority** (Nice to have)

7. **Quality Gates (`qg`)** - Add validation framework
8. **Error Optimization (`eo`)** - Add analysis framework

## 🔧 **Recommended Actions**

### **1. Complete Strategy Implementation**

```python
# Add to strategy_protocols.py
def initialize_red_team(task, blue_team_size=3, red_team_size=3):
def initialize_mob_programming(task, agent_count=4):

# Add to agent_coordination.py
def select_strategy(project_analysis):
```

### **2. Add Missing Templates**

```python
# Add to project_planning_templates.py
def generate_strategic_planning_template():
def generate_architecture_review_template():
def generate_team_management_template():
def generate_quality_gates_template():
def generate_error_optimization_template():
```

### **3. Connect Hotkeys to Implementations**

```python
# Update README_ai.md hotkey documentation to match actual implementations
# Ensure every documented hotkey has a working implementation
```

## ✅ **What's Working Well**

1. **Core Analysis Tools** - All code exploration hotkeys work perfectly
2. **Snapshot System** - Complete implementation with templates and protocols
3. **Basic Strategies** - PD, Pipeline, Swarm have full implementation
4. **Memory Synchronization** - Git branch-based memory system works reliably
5. **Bundle Mode** - Complete documentation and implementation
6. **Agent Discovery** - New coordination protocols work well

## 🎯 **Conclusion**

**Current State**: ~70% of documented features are fully implemented
**Main Gaps**: Strategy execution protocols, planning templates, team management
**Biggest Issue**: Strategy selection (`ss`) documented but not connected to implementations
**Harmonization**: Generally good, few conflicts, mostly missing implementations

**Next Steps**: Focus on completing strategy implementations and connecting documented hotkeys to actual functions.
